Hey there! I'm new to paper MTG and play Commander with my playgroup. We've been having a debate about whether the total value of a deck really indicates how strong it is. One of my friends argues that value doesn't equal strength, but I can't help but wonder when I keep losing to a deck with a higher price tag than mine.
I've been playing 1v1 games with my friend for a few months now, so I know their deck almost as well as mine. It can be frustrating when I can predict their moves but still can't win with my basic deck. I understand the point that a couple of expensive cards in a deck won't guarantee a win, but when a deck is upgraded with so many pricey cards, it feels like a whole different ball game.
For reference, we both started with precons, and both upgraded. I spent $20, they spent $120+. Inputing my deck list in a deck value calculator returns $103, which is lower than their upgrade alone lol
I don't mind losing when the match is good. I hate losing when I'm always on the backfoot and can't do much besides hoping to survive another turn
What are your thoughts on this? I'd love to hear different perspectives on the relationship between deck value and strength in the game.
edit: I received more responses than I expected, so I'll need some time to go through them all and respond. Thank you in advance!
Consider playing a couple games where you swap decks. Commander players are used to downplaying their decks' strengths and other decks' weaknesses. Maybe you're wrong and you just need to learn some strategy fundamentals, but it sounds likely that there really is a significant deck power disparity.
However, if that is the case, it's possible that your deck's shortcomings could be fixed without having to spend more than $5 on a single card. Adding more removal, removing duds, simplifying your game plan, or improving your mana base could help keep you in the game.
Oh also I would be derelict in my duties if I did not remind you that proxying cards is good and everyone should do it all the time. If your play group doesn't allow proxies, they suck and you should start looking for some cool people to play with.
That sounds interesting, thanks for the suggestion. We'll definitely consider it!
I'll have to understand where exactly is the "issue" lying, first. We both have creature-heavy decks, but mine has weaker creatures that "waste" mana because they don't bring much to the table compared to what theirs do, not to mention the fact that they can play more creatures than me each turn thanks to the basic mechanics of their deck
We considered this as well, but we haven't decided on how to do it! For the moment we're good with just our cards without venturing there!
coincidentally, the Youtuber Salubrious Snail just released a video that's directly relevant to your question
That makes sense! The situation I'm talking about is in commander duel, though, and it's tough to run too many interactions without sacrificing playing time, haha. I do have a good amount of spot removal (6) and board wipes (3), so I really can't add any more to my deck.
The problem is that my opponent can quickly build up a board of better and bigger creatures than I can, and since both of our decks rely on creature damage to win, adding more removal wouldn't do much good (postpone thw inevitable by a couple turns at best). Every removal spell I add takes away a creature from my deck (even though they might not be the best, having a creature is better than nothing) and that messes with my strategy.
I don't have any combo pieces in my deck; I focused on making it consistent rather than aiming for a big explosive combo. So, according to the video, I'm not doing anything wrong.
When we both had stock precons, the matches were more evenly balanced. But after they upgraded with more expensive and better creatures, I haven't won a single game, haha. The one time I did win was because they missed several land drops and I got some lucky draws lol