I have an accelerationist mindset for MTG alone. I hope that the game's brand continues to deteriorate as a result of Hasbro's actions to the point where people start en masse printing their own proxy sets in the system and doing cube-style drafts incorporating some new or redesigned cards along with the old system.
He's so correct about the rarity system particularly lands, a basic feature like dual-color lands has evolved into this kind of chase collector item worth hundreds of dollars. Eliminating mana screw and making mono color mechanics more distinctive and powerful would probably be my immediate focus if I could get people offline involved in weird custom cube drafts. Xmage has some pretty creative people, and you can actually play with the custom cards, I wonder what Garfield thinks about it or if he knows about proxying.
So far, fwiw, the best take on solving mana screw imo has been what the game Sorcery Contested Realm has done. You have a 40 card deck and a separate 20 card lands deck. In Magic you would start with 4 spells and 3 lands, one free mulligan in both decks, and then you draw from either deck for the turn. Cards would have to be erratad en masse to make this work in Magic, but I think Arena kinda solves it with "seeking" a land vs. a spell. I don't know how that works in Magic outside of at least smoothing an opening hand. The game would need to refer to the deck separately from the "atlas" of lands.
I have an accelerationist mindset for MTG alone. I hope that the game's brand continues to deteriorate as a result of Hasbro's actions to the point where people start en masse printing their own proxy sets in the system and doing cube-style drafts incorporating some new or redesigned cards along with the old system.
He's so correct about the rarity system particularly lands, a basic feature like dual-color lands has evolved into this kind of chase collector item worth hundreds of dollars. Eliminating mana screw and making mono color mechanics more distinctive and powerful would probably be my immediate focus if I could get people offline involved in weird custom cube drafts. Xmage has some pretty creative people, and you can actually play with the custom cards, I wonder what Garfield thinks about it or if he knows about proxying.
So far, fwiw, the best take on solving mana screw imo has been what the game Sorcery Contested Realm has done. You have a 40 card deck and a separate 20 card lands deck. In Magic you would start with 4 spells and 3 lands, one free mulligan in both decks, and then you draw from either deck for the turn. Cards would have to be erratad en masse to make this work in Magic, but I think Arena kinda solves it with "seeking" a land vs. a spell. I don't know how that works in Magic outside of at least smoothing an opening hand. The game would need to refer to the deck separately from the "atlas" of lands.