I have an idea for campaign in my head but I need to find a good system to run it. Main thing I want is a system that would allow people to play humans, humanoids, and non-humans, with enough system and character customization depth to make the differences feel interesting and meaningful. Basically, if a player wants to be a fire magic-wielding phoenix or a psychic cat, they should be able to do that.
Ideally the system would also have at least some level of support for typical fantasy adventuring stuff (dungeon crawling, combat, social intrigue, etc.)
GURPS is a generic system with some of the most extensive customization imaginable, which is a double-edged sword because while it means you can make anything, it won't always be easy. The default character is a human (~6 feet tall, two arms with hands, two legs with feet, two eyes, etc) and everything is built off of that. It being generic is also double-edged, because it means that the GM needs to determine which rules and options they're enabling. For instance, there are like 6 magic systems, and I personally would recommend the Sorcery system, as it enables free-form casting.
For example's sake, the traits of the phoenix with fire magic would look something like this:
More system stuff:
Thanks for taking the time to make such a detailed writeup! I have absolutely no experience with GURPS, but I can definitely appreciate the scale of its ambition, and I have enough experience with TTRPGs that I'm more excited by the possibilities than scared by the complexity of a highly detailed system system (I just hope it's not too complex for prospective players). I'll definitely consider it in addition to Pathfinder.
Nice try, @Dirt_Owl@hexbear.net
In my experience, the best way to avoid this is to ask them what type of character they want and to make it for them.
Yeah, after getting past them past that frontloading it quickly becomes pretty straightforward even for players that haven't read the rules.
Makes sense.
One last question, I'm thinking I might also want to toss in some ancient advanced civilization stuff and robot characters. Any recommendations for those?
First off, do NOT just take stuff from High-Tech or Ultra Tech and plug it into your game. The numbers will not work with a low-tech fantasy game , and would have to be drastically adjusted, though you can of course use them for ideas.
Since we're back on designing your own stuff again, the first thing is to decide what rules you actually need for your players to interact with the ancient tech satisfactorily. Imo this comes down to how to use/repair ancient tech, and stats for robots. Equipment can be built as powers the same way you would build any other magic items, though if you're really dedicated you could work out an entire separate system for the technology/magic to really make them feel distinct. If so, Thaumatology is generally the book to look to, as it contains a bunch of magic systems, though they will all take some work to implement fully into a campaign. A lot of GURPS stuff will suggest using Quick Gadgeteer for high-tech gadgets but imo that's a really hand-wavey system that's not very interesting.
The main thing is going to be getting the numbers right. Damage and armor for laser guns or robots just need to be pretty close to what players can do. For damage, a single-target laser beam-type attack should cap out around 6d damage (which is a lot), area effects like flamethrowers should cap out around 2-3d, and armor should never get that much higher than the heaviest plate armor which IIRC is around DR12. Robots probably have Damage Tolerance: Unliving, since they don't have vital organs (unless you want them to), and Electrical or even Vulnerability (Electricity) to represent a susceptibility to lightning magic. As for pieces of ancient aliens tech, maybe they need ammunition in the form of ancient battery packs, or are vulnerable to electricity, or have a malfunction rating (which might be higher if used by someone who doesn't know what they're doing) where when attempting to use them they can "jam" (or explode!) and need to be fixed before they can be used again.
In terms of PCs interacting with ancient stuff, maybe add a Hidden Lore (Ancient Civilizations) skill to understand the writings and tools of the ancients (eg knowing what an "On/Off" switch looks like), and Engineer (Ancient Technology) to use/repair ancient tech. A full Language (Ancient Civilizations) is also possible if you want them to be able to talk to robots without the robots having to know whatever the setting's default language is.
All very good stuff, thanks!
There are many GURPS genre books which can help with building nonhuman characters - Space, Fantasy, there's even a recent Furries book for anthropomorphic nonhumans, the old 3e Monsters/Shifters books are, well, less helpful but neat.
The Technomancer setting (really neat modern day magic setting, albeit one that drops the line "a resurrected Stalin fights to take back control of the USSR" and barely follows up on it - the Penguin Hivemind gets more attention) has a half dozen human-animal chimaera races that were updated in a later issue of Pyramid.