Do the advantages of deleting one's entire Reddit history outweigh the disadvantages?

I have previously nuked my first Reddit account because it felt satisfactory to be completely detached from a platform one considers unethical/bad. Though, I have garnered quite some history on a second account—because Duty Calls*, of course—and I'm considering doing the same.

However, I don't want to do it impulsively. I think I might be blind to some disadvantages. What do you think?

*

Show

  • DLSantini@lemmy.ml
    ·
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    What disadvantages? Losing fake internet points? I deleted every post and comment I had ever made, as well as my account, several years ago. It has negatively impacted my life in exactly zero ways. Look man, no offense, but you're not erasing the works of Shakespeare over here. The world will keep on turning just fine if you delete your collection of memes and shit posts.

    • Artyom@lemm.ee
      ·
      edit-2
      3 months ago

      You may be deleting your comments in the hopes that it will pull some value away from Reddit. That's not true, in fact, the opposite is more likely. They will still keep the deleted posts in their archives, and they will still be able to train their AI models on the content. The difference is that now they get an extra datapoint: these are the kind of comments of someone who left Reddit and deleted their account/comments. If you deleted them right after leaving, that means they can place your account deletion in time around the API changes, which will also contribute to their AI profile.

      • ᗪᗩᗰᑎ@lemmy.ml
        ·
        3 months ago

        You may be deleting your comments in the hopes that it will pull some value away from Reddit. That’s not true, in fact, the opposite is more likely.

        I would disagree.

        If reddit was only about linking websites you would be correct, but that's not where all the value comes from. Some of the value comes from the comments. Comments provide insights, provide celebrity interaction (snoop, arnold, bill gates, etc), a sense of community, technical knowledge, stories, warnings, context as well as many other things that end-users find valuable.

        Remove the comments, ipso facto, you remove value.

      • Orcocracy [comrade/them]
        ·
        3 months ago

        AI, algorithms, and the statistics that power them are not that smart. They have no way of knowing for sure what is in your head when you hit the delete button.

  • quarrk [he/him]
    ·
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    Thesis: Nuking your reddit account is good for your mental health

    Antithesis: If everyone nuked their reddit accounts, a lot of invaluable information (especially in niche communities) would be lost, and this would primarily hurt average people and not reddit as a corporation

    Synthesis: Nuking all reddit accounts is good for society's health. Reddit is a trash website. In the short-term it will hurt, but long-term we are better off moving these communities to decentralized platforms. There are ways to archive the important information from reddit. Reddit thrives off the free contributions of countless users who are paid nothing, and reddit claims ownership and monetizes all content freely published to it. If you don't like reddit, simply stop posting to it, no matter how juicy the bait

  • oscardejarjayes [comrade/them]
    ·
    3 months ago

    imo you should, before nuking your account, make a backup of everything you said, and maybe some of the surrounding context, and then host it on a website. Just make sure your website is all properly indexed, and shows up when you use the right search terms. I have no idea what the legality of such an undertaking would be, but it would be cool. Or, if you don't want to bother with that, you could try writing some blog posts based off of the correct answers you gave to obscure questions.

    But really, it all depends on what you did with you Reddit account. If you answered people's obscure questions, you should keep that information. Would someone look up a question you answered? Did you talk a lot in more technical subreddits? Did those arguments you have result in any positive change? But if you spent all your time on big threads with thousands of other people replying, or did a bunch of lurking, maybe your account isn't worth keeping.

    If you account is only of value to you, maybe just downoad a copy of everyhting you've said on there, then nuke your account with some tool.

  • geekwithsoul@lemm.ee
    ·
    3 months ago

    I had a Reddit account I opened in July 2009 that was fairly active and I deleted all my posts and comments when I left - mainly because I felt I couldn’t trust the company that ran it to be good stewards of the content and decided they weren’t entitled to it. All the stuff that’s happened in the last year has just reinforced that conclusion.

    Reddit makes money off the content everyone contributes (as well as the hard work of so many unpaid folks doing moderation) and that’s not a model I choose to support. Some of the conversations I was involved in had really help information on a number of topics, and while I’m sad that information isn’t still available to others, I think the overall good is better served by not supporting a site so at odds with my beliefs.

  • Jo Miran@lemmy.ml
    ·
    3 months ago

    I changed every link in my posts, then deleted every post, replaced every comment with excerpts from literature in the public domain, then replaced the modified comments with gibberish before deleting them. Was that enough? No, but still better than allowing Reddit to profit from me without any effort. If they want my shit, they'll have to pull from archive, and even then it might be a bit of Moby Dick.

  • NeroC_Bass@lemmy.dbzer0.com
    ·
    3 months ago

    With duck duck go not really showing reddit results anymore, I'd say it doesnt matter. I'm finding more forums for niche things that generally are more helpful instead of full of trolls and inb4 posts.

  • Annoyed_🦀 @monyet.cc
    ·
    3 months ago

    Edit it instead of deleting it, but then i doubt it's useful because they can revert everything. Before i moved i did a mass edit using plugin and even after a few days, some comment stay the same while others is successfully edited.

    There's just no disadvantage of dumping your abusive SO though.

  • Joël de Bruijn@lemmy.ml
    ·
    3 months ago

    Loosing vast amounts of historical posts or would I say "cultural heritage" is a shame but I couldn't trust the party hosting it ...

    So with Twitter I did the same, 13 years of tweets. Even took a one month payment on a bulk erase / unlike / unfollow / unretweet service to get it done in a reasonable amount of time.