Here's what I'm reading:

Show

Show

Show

Show

Show

Show

I'm going to stop reading A Dance with Dragons and the two Star Wars books for now and wrap up Empire, Incorporated and Determined while I continue on with Das Kapital.

Bonus question:

What do you PLAN to read later on?

Enjoy!

  • ComradeOohAah [he/him, they/them]
    hexbear
    2
    3 months ago

    It sounds like you're combining agency into your definition of free will. Yes, the mechanisms of your body's behavior (choices) are occurring inside your body, you have agency. But, Free Will implies that the mind has the ability to direct those choices beyond the realm of the material world's laws (i.e. physic; most especially, inertia.)

    • jack [he/him, comrade/them]
      hexbear
      2
      3 months ago

      Free Will implies that the mind has the ability to direct those choices beyond the realm of the material world's laws

      Does it? I don't see why that's the case. This claims that there is simply no such thing as a materialist concept of free will. That's creating a definition so narrow that it cancels itself out. In what way is free will different from agency? You operate from an assumption that the "the mind" is only valid if in some way immaterial, but why should that be?

      I mean, really, what is the difference between free will and agency? If your definition of agency is just free will but material, then nothing about the conclusions you draw is any different from a materialist conception of free will and you have achieved nothing philosophically or scientifically.

      • ComradeOohAah [he/him, they/them]
        hexbear
        1
        3 months ago

        To be honest, I'm not really interested in getting into it, I just wanted to clarify a conflation I thought you were making. You wanna hold on to those definitions it's fine by me.