Key Points:

…after spending the last few months periodically poking around the trees inhabited by little birdies, I do have good news for fans of coercive government regulation,” Gruber says. “Apple’s hand was effectively forced. But by China, not the EU.”

“Coercive government regulation” lmao.

Gruber points to a new law in the works in China that will require that 5G devices support RCS in order to receive certification in the country.

Chinese carriers have been proponents of RCS for years, and last year, the Chinese government began the process of codifying into law that to achieve certification, new 5G devices will be required to support RCS. Shockingly, the Chinese government seemingly isn’t concerned that the RCS standard has no provisions for encryption. The little birdies I’ve spoken to all said the same thing: iOS support for RCS is all about China.

“Shockingly”.

Apple would prefer simply to continue ignoring RCS, on the grounds that they want to support neither any new non-E2EE protocols, nor any new carrier-controlled protocols (whether encrypted or not). But when the CCP says device makers must jump to sell their products in China, Apple asks “How high?”

The sheer Sinophobia omg.

One narrative in the months since Apple’s RCS announcement in November has been that the move was driven by the Digital Markets Act in the European Union. The DMA, however, makes no mention of RCS specifically – and now have official confirmation that iMessage is not big enough in the EU to fall under the purview of the DMA.

There goes EU, the saviour of digital rights.

Anyways, what an article.

  • VHS [he/him]
    ·
    5 months ago

    Do you think they would write in the same paranoid fashion about the EU forcing Apple to adopt USB-C? In both cases the "coercive" government is making them provide a better product where market forces failed

    • buckykat [none/use name]
      ·
      5 months ago

      There were definitely articles complaining about the EU big government restricting Apple's innovation for the next time they try to make a proprietary plug in the hypothetical future

    • RustyVenture [he/him]
      ·
      5 months ago

      Yes, actually. At least for the USB-C thing. John Gruber has always been one of the most insufferable Apple sycophants out there. When I was a teenager and in my early 20s I had thought he caught a bit too much flak for his takes and thought most of his justifications were sound (this is also likely because I was an Apple user myself and wanted the things he said to be true), but around 2016-17 he also started weighing in more on politics (massive turbolib) and it broke me out of that bubble right quick.

      Since the pandemic started he's become an even more unbearable asshole with bad takes, and it looks like they're only getting worse.