I used to think that even though Apple's bad, at least they're okay on the privacy front. But what the fuck?
They wanna be able to detect every image I take for the possibility of it being "illegal"? Fuck you.
Is Ubuntu good? And LineageOS for phone?
Edit - At least r/apple seems to be against it If there's one positive thing I can say about reddit, it's that those nerds are usually all in on privacy stuff.
I'm not sure what you mean by this, but they definitely are using hashes to detect illegal images:
I thought they hashed result of some pattern network, to avoid pixel changing behaviour of straight hashes?
Ah yes, in the technical summary it details their hashing algorithm; it takes some digging to actually find that, I note. I admit to being dubious that their NeuralHash algorithm is really as bulletproof as they seem to be saying it is; neural nets are, in my view, a shitty foundation for any algorithm.
So, on the one hand, this wipes out point 2 (as OP already mentioned), but on the other, anyone with a very large photo collection on iCloud is at real risk of having their images viewed by random Apple employees, which is pretty gross. (I was wondering why they would need a threshold rather than just booting someone for any such image.)