I'm fairly critical, so there's not too many on my list, but the biggest one is that I liked Quest 64 (somehow) when I was younger.
I also love La Mulana 1&2, along with Deadly Premonition, though those are more "cult hits" aka critical failures that 'widely disliked'. But, I'd definitely hesitate to recommend any of them to someone unless I thought they'd be into it.
One of these days I'm going to play Cyberpunk 2077 solely so I can watch the Action Button review of it
IIRC you could watch the AB review without being very spoiled; during the choose-your-own-adventure segments, you just have to choose the ones that don't focus on the game.