My Guard vs buddy's AdMech, still playing 9th because 10th fucked both our factions, doing Tempest because fixed objectives suck. Also only 1k points. I brought a bit of a meme list because my guard have been undefeated in our play group (vanquisher russ w/ the reroll tank ace, deathstrike, ogryn instead of bullgryn, triple scout sentinels in a single unit with plasma cannons that I intended to charge with). The weird thing is that this objectively worse version of my list costs more points, thank you James Workshop.
Highlights:
- A deathstrike doing literally nothing all game because it's so easy to avoid (I could have taken the lame missiles but it's godslayer or nothing)
- The Vanquisher Russ needing to command reroll 2 wound rolls to do anything (though it did one-shot an onager and kill two breachers)
- The Datasmith just charging a plasma Russ and living the rest of his days in melee because I had nothing to charge him with and nothing with good enough shooting to justify falling back
- 3 sentinels living in melee with a tech priest all game while holding his deployment objective
- Only living models at end of game: deathstrike, 2 tech priests, 3 skitarii rangers
Final Score: Guard 67-AdMech 37
At least competitively, Deathwatch is in a pretty good place, right around the top 5. As for casual play, well, you never know, but they clearly at least have some tools.
Maybe it's a skill issue then
The only person with a skill issue is James Workshop, who cannot write a balanced set of rules to save his life.
that is a feature. if you designed a good edition you wouldn't be able to sell another