• Lemmy_Mouse@lemmygrad.ml
    ·
    2 years ago

    Browns combined the right and the left into a political leadership over the country, Shea is speaking of bolstering the anti-war movement's numbers and thus power with the right instead.

    "that “these people aren’t interested in liberation, they’re only out for self and for kin.”"

    This is not how he comes off to me but you are entitled to your opinion.

    "I am still not convinced that concepts like Haywood’s Black Belt Republic aren’t the direction my folk should be going in"

    Black Americans do not have the numbers to accomplish such a task as a Black Republic and hold it without the US bourgeois state along with the Canadian lapdog seizing the land back. This just isn't realistic. If you want your people to be free, socialism is the best way to achieve such goals because it takes into account the interests of all workers equally. It does not cater only to the needs of black workers, no, however this is not something Marxism aims to do.

    "definitely won’t long-knife y’all when your usefulness is through”, that tells me that your movement is predicated on anyone else’s sacrifice but your own, and leaves me considering you as deeply unserious to the point of being literally hazardous to any oppressed folk in your orbit."

    I understand your distrust however I remind you that even utilizing race relations analytics defensively is still viewing the world on terms of race. Marx shows us that method of analysis is useless, it is one which serves to create and then re-enforce capitalism.

    • Black AOC@lemmygrad.ml
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      I understand your distrust however I remind you that even utilizing race relations analytics defensively is still viewing the world on terms of race. Marx shows us that method of analysis is useless, it is one which serves to create and then re-enforce capitalism.

      I keep coming back to this point because y'all keep doing it: lifting hundred-year old theory with no brushup on what your actual material conditions are. In Marx's time, there was no understanding of the two Amerikas. He looked at it as a singular beast as though we were just another England or France; but that is not the case. In my Amerika, in the Amerika anyone who looks like me is relegated to, we don't get the luxury to not analyze things on a racial line, because that is how the state and how the society both punish us for not staying in our perceived place, never fuckin mind assimilation.

      Like, do you realize that when there's only one or two Black folk in a room full of crackers, those Black folk immediately know two things: that they're now 'the fly in the milk' as far as this gathering is concerned, and that the odds of one of those hypothetical white people getting buck and calling cops on us, regardless of what the function says it's for, has skyrocketed? In an age where you've got white cops-- and shit, sometimes Tom-assed Sunken Place'd Black cops blowing us away, we don't get that luxury. We have to know what the danger is, where the danger is, know where the exit is, and have a plan to get there before anything; and right now, I'm seeing all the warning signs of needing an exit.

      You might as well ask a fireman to divest himself of PPE before tending to a five-alarm call.