I'm using "internet horror" as an umbrella term for any horror fiction that presents itself as, or is about, something "found on the internet." This can be anything from a story formatted as a blog post about something terrifying that happened to the author, to cursed image stories like Smile Dog.

I'll start:

Ted the Caver: Originally posted as an Angelfire site that has since unfortunately been taken down. Chronicles the journey of a caver who gradually discovers that the cave he's exploring has something living in it.

The Story of TRAINING.bsp: A blog reminiscing about the author's days exploring strange custom Half-Life maps with his clan. One of these maps takes a sinister turn.

The Dionaea House: A series of emails and text messages about a strange house. Or rather, a strange thing pretending to be a house.

    • Wisp [fae/faer, any]
      ·
      4 years ago

      devolves into stupidity towards the end

      I feel like that's most creepy pasta tbh

    • BeamBrain [he/him]
      hexagon
      ·
      4 years ago

      Basically, yeah.

      Agreed about the NES Godzilla Creepypasta. It got its hooks into me fast and went strong for a while, but then it utterly failed to stick the landing.