That's a fair criticism - doomer is not really a useful term. It just sucks that the information environment being as it is means getting flooded with contradictory accounts all the time. But no one, not the western media, not resistance media, thought this was at all possible not too long ago.
Damn, that helicopter crash might be the most important air accident in history
Idk I feel like you're dooming too much. The US always has primary and secondary objectives for their evil operations and they would definitely have preferred a fully comprador Iraq rather than a weak state with the PMFs openly fighting them. It has yet to be seen if Syria will end up the same way but I think it's more likely that happens than they end up with a fascist Lebanon-type regime. I feel like Turkey would also rather go after the Kurds first than Iraq, no?
"Self-defense" like the Marco Polo bridge incident was self-defense
I think you misunderstood what I'm saying. He still has those cases pending against him. If there's a 1% chance he goes to jail when he ends these genocides, but a 0% chance while he keeps them going, he has every incentive to continue a perpetual state of war until he can coup the supreme Zionist court or whatever. Especially while Biden bends over backwards for "lethad aid" in every way possible.
I don't understand your point about the proxy. You're saying the Palestinian/Lebanese resistance is fucked because they've got no supply now but they also shouldn't have sent troops to support one of their most important supply lines? How does that work?
Also, the IRA managed to get weapons smuggled overseas from Libya. Just because an important route will become more difficult (and a strong enough state to prevent smuggling is going to take a while) doesn't mean it's instantly Joever ™️.
I didn't say he was and I'm not parroting anything. Notice how you said popular again, as in he was super unpopular before the genocides and pursued them because Israel loves genocide.
I don't think Israel went full Sherlock Holmes and predicted the future about it being bad for the resistance. The PFLP and the communist factions in Gaza supported the operation. It's that Israel's prime minister doesn't want to go to jail so he needs to keep war going as long as possible - another leader would likely have pulled out months ago and not attacked Lebanon Iran and Syria. The craven bloodthirst of the Biden admin, unprecedented even for the United States, is what allowed the genocide(s) to continue for this long - as opposed to the cowardice of Iran giving them no backstop.
Hamas and Hezbollah are still in a relatively strong position, it's not time to doom because an incompetent unpopular regime got Afghanistan-ed.
Yes it's a very common take but I don't think it's correct. Bob basically makes this exact speech when arguing with Helen in the house, and then proceeds to nearly get his entire family killed to sate his own ego. Syndrome is literally a consequence of Bob's superiority complex not allowing him to treat a normal person with dignity.
I think that @plinky is right in that they clearly aren't Marxists, but I also think you have a "geopolitical" view of how states make decisions. While they are influenced by the idiosyncrasies of individuals, governments are effectively a tangled, writhing mass of competing class interests and the decisions made reflect this and nothing more.
Iran/China continually tries to achieve rapprochement with their mortal enemies not because of some rationalistic calculus (which would be incorrect anyway), but because there are capitalist interests that push them to do so. In the case of Iran under Khomeini they had more of a planned economy so those interests superseded this of mercantile businesses who would benefit greatly from removing sanctions. China is in a similar situation which was eroded by their integration into the global market.
Only a country like the DPRK can choose to pursue self-reliance via a socialist dictatorship, and this it was able to survive an apocalyptic crisis and become effectively impregnable to imperialism.
do you have a source? seems insane to believe that anyone would honour israel's attempts at negotiation
I assume not responding to Haniyeh's assassination and then the new president basically saying Hezbollah's gonna lose
More like "living space".
What the hell are you talking about?
No, they are both allying with rightists but in one case it "might be seen as a last resort to make visible the violation of their political rights, as well as some cases of human rights violations against SIDOR workers". The situation isn't as clear cut as you think, and I never said neoliberalism was the alternative
https://orinocotribune.com/luigino-bracci-sometimes-you-wonder-if-some-psuv-members-are-playing-for-the-same-team-as-chavismo-interview/
Except that the first united front led to the nationalists obliterating the communist side, and the second led to Mao learning from that and barely actually coordinating with the KMT and retaining their independence. Funny enough, that is more analagous to what the PCV's shift is than whatever argument you are making. Especially since the PSUV's response during this entire crisis has been to punch left as much as possible
https://venezuelanalysis.com/news/communist-party-of-venezuela-decries-usurpation-by-supreme-court/
This is an entirely different thought
Maduro is an incompetent right wing social democrat who has been doing everything possible to destroy the PCV, who were allied with the PSUV. This goes up to stripping them of political rights and legally replacing the party's leadership with cronies. You're essentially calling for the KPD to unite with the SPD because of tRoTsKy
The shit is that if Sanders either got the nomination or grew a pair of balls big enough so he would run as an independent, he would beat both in a landslide
Didn't the resistance ask him to open a front in the Golan after Oct 7 and he said no in order to pursue normalisation?