The Wandering Earth 2 is not simplistic and you've probably missed a lot since you aren't fluent in the language, because you can't capture the nuances yourself and you aren't able to go into Chinese-langauge spaces to see what other people have found. I also have no clue who the two people you mentioned in the pop music bit are, but idk why you are talking about them instead of hugely popular musicians like Phoenix Legend or Li Yuchun, both of whose works very much have evolved throughout their careers.

There are a lot of structural factors when it comes to Chinese cultural products having less impact in the imperial core. I think you discount the lack of exposure. Even if there was some Chinese media that you personally feel is innovative blah blah, do you think the imperial core would let it get popular? So idek why that is a gripe that you have.

You have valid critiques (and people in China complain about capital being lazy and not producing more creative films and tv shows), but a lot of this post sounds like lack of cultural self-confidence on your part, as well as viewing Chinese media through a Western lens/palate tbh.

I learnt an instrument at school, and I also presume that not all school kids in the US get to learn an instrument.

School workloads are being reduced. The problem right now is with the parents forcing their kids to compete.

Thanks for such a calm and non-combative answer. I do understand why people can get combative, but that sort of thing usually doesn't help change people's minds.

It really just depends on which country/company you'd trust more with your data imo. Like even on the comparison site https://www.securemessagingapps.com/, there isn't a single company with non-iffy company and infrastructure jurisdiction, and one would have to manually check the funding section since they list Signal as good on there (as they obviously haven't checked that one of the funders has fed connections).

https://yasha.substack.com/p/signal-is-a-government-op-85e

The from 2013 through 2016 link only goes to the homepage now, but you can find Signal as a supported project here: https://www.opentech.fund/projects-we-support/supported-projects/?sc=&filter1=&filter2=&order-by-selector=date-desc&pageno=7

I've been able to pull it out, and usually they can be re-used without any problems.

It's pretty easy to identify bots and libs from what they post, and I'm sure they'll know to ignore those.

Shanghai does. They have a reputation (at least online) for being full of libs.

The rolling R in Spanish is not easy for a lot of people, for example, me, a native speaker of a Chinese language.

生日快乐！

For Chinese comrades stuck in a family of libs who love the US, we don't get that respite :(

A lot of Chinese shows can be watched for free on YT (and with English subs iirc). Most of the big channels have channels on there and they post their shows for free viewing.

Signal's got fed connections, though, iirc.

Fascinating, thanks for the post!

No, the rules weren't even implemented in the first place. It's still in the phase of public consultation.

These new 'rules' are only in the phase of public consultation right now. So this is like a non-story in the first place. Also, from what I understand, the youth wing is very engaged.

Good luck!