What if someone did a takedown of Pokemon that fully explores the implications, but the thing is that a takedown of Pokemon cannot be fun. If its fun then its just grimdark Pokemon. Its "do not do this cool thing" ludonarrative dissonance. Youre not getting anything truly cool out of that.

We it would need to be a pain to play. Like Spec Ops: The Line, but Pokemon. Or maybe Undertale: Genocide Run but Pokemon specifically instead of JRPGs generally?

Palworld is definitly not that lol. It revels in the fucked upness as far as i can tell. It doesnt even shame you so you dont even get the "do not do this cool thing" aspect. And it endevors to be fun (ymmv on success).

But Im wondering if a game that says to Pokemon what Spec Ops: The Line said to military FPSes is possible?

  • buckykat [none/use name]
    ·
    5 months ago

    Undertale is overrated and the bit of "you did the rpg thing oooooohh what a bad person you are" is dumb

    • autismdragon [he/him, comrade/them]
      hexagon
      ·
      5 months ago

      Honestly? Thank you for saying it lol. (I also feel that theres ableist implications, not that Toby Fox intended them but yuknow).

    • WithoutFurtherBelay
      ·
      5 months ago

      Actually it’s a really solid critique of how we are constantly instilled with the instinct to obtain and develop power from all the media we consume in the West, intentional or not

        • WithoutFurtherBelay
          ·
          edit-2
          5 months ago

          Yes but it got very popular in Western countries, and for some reason I doubt the original bug catching context was the reason why

          Edit: thought this was in the Pokémon threads, nvm