ngl russia is not making it easy to give critical support lol

  • HeavenAndEarth [she/her]
    ·
    5 months ago

    Are we sure that a revolutionary strategy developed in the context of WWI is relevant in 2024?

    Anyone who would in all earnest refute the “slogan” of defeat for one’s own government in the imperialist war should prove one of three things: (1) that the war of 1914-15 is not reactionary, or (2) that a revolution stemming from that war is impossible, or (3) that co-ordination and mutual aid are possible between revolutionary movements in all the belligerent countries.

    -The Defeat of One’s Own Government in the Imperialist War

    Like, I don't think 2 or 3 are currently possible in the Russia Ukraine war, or most of the ongoing conflicts for that matter.

    • WithoutFurtherBelay
      ·
      5 months ago

      Well, you could argue a revolution will “stem” from the Ukraine-Russia conflict because it weakens the extremely counter-revolutionary US, and it is indeed impossible or extremely difficult for there to be any sort of mutual aid and cooperation between the two country’s working class movements, because of sanctions. Finally, it is a very reactionary war in general, literally headed by Nazis on one side and one of the people who helped collapse the USSR on the other, so this is seeming like a textbook case of proper use of revolutionary defeatism to me.