Even though all good leftists know this is a false choice. The only correct path is that of Volcel Geralt who gets to chill with Ciri on his vineyard, hunt monsters and sleep under a tree. This is the pinnacle of the Dudes Rock lifestyle.
Fuckboi Geralt is a distant second since he's like 200 years old and should simply not be fucking anyone.
I only played the Witcher 3 and went with Triss because she seems way more pleasant if you don’t know the backstory. Yennefer seems so cold and manipulative, but you don’t get that she’s doing a lot of what she does for Ciri and that she truly does love Geralt. It makes the story kind of sad at the end.