Other than current traction towards matrix marketing, why do so few people use XMPP? Most people just sign up for the matrix.org accounts which are hosted in Britain. One can use one of the other Matrix hosts, but I don't understand why people use matrix instead of XMPP.
Encryption was an afterthought with xmpp, whereas matrix was designed with encryption first. Xmpp has encryption as an extension, but not all clients support it.
XMPP is cool but so many things that you'd expect to be standard are extensions that both the Server and all the Clients need to have installed and enabled. Also some XMPP clients don't support all extensions and some extensions also require third party software and extra setup. Matrix just works.
That being said signing up to matrix.org is cringe. Absolutely host your own homeserver.
Its illegal for Signal to tell you if they have a backdoor, because of US key disclosure laws. Check out the EFF's article on NSLs, and why every US-based service can't be trusted.
The data signal gives to state governments, is likely different from the info it gives to the federal goverment.
Very resourceful links! Thanks! I wasn't doubting there are issues regarding Signal, especially considering its ties to the US, as I saw a video regarding its controversies. My point I wanted to make is there is no 100% secure application, and there will be bugs and vulnerabilities among applications we think we can trust. I believe Signal is still a major improvement regarding security, at least compared to Discord, but I would prefer XMPP, Matrix, etc. if I had the choice. Though I understand if an encrypted system is compromised, it's just as a good as being unencrypted, so if it turns out the US is getting sufficient information from Signal through a backdoor and the subpoena I mentioned was just for show, I hope PSL would consider migrating to Matrix or something more trustworthy. Then again, when the going gets tough, we may have to abandon our phones and electronics to stay safe and find ways to make revolutionary change under a police state.
For sure, and thank you for doing this work for your branch. Enough people need to push for the use of more secure platforms, (esp getting off google), and I hope that eventually becomes a mandatory directive, not just for PSL, but all parties.
Matrix. Signal is a centralized, US company. That alone is enough to disqualify it.
Other than current traction towards matrix marketing, why do so few people use XMPP? Most people just sign up for the matrix.org accounts which are hosted in Britain. One can use one of the other Matrix hosts, but I don't understand why people use matrix instead of XMPP.
Encryption was an afterthought with xmpp, whereas matrix was designed with encryption first. Xmpp has encryption as an extension, but not all clients support it.
XMPP is cool but so many things that you'd expect to be standard are extensions that both the Server and all the Clients need to have installed and enabled. Also some XMPP clients don't support all extensions and some extensions also require third party software and extra setup. Matrix just works.
That being said signing up to matrix.org is cringe. Absolutely host your own homeserver.
Even Matrix isn't perfect. I would consider Signal and Matrix to be pretty secure and recommended for activist organization, until the US decides to force Signal to open a backdoor into its end-to-end encryption. Signal only provided the account number, last connection date, and account creation date (in unix time format, lol) when the California grand jury issued a subpoena. Signal has also threatened to leave the US and the UK if they passed their anti-encryption bills.
Signal is not without criticism, though, considering their controversial cryptocurrency project.
Its illegal for Signal to tell you if they have a backdoor, because of US key disclosure laws. Check out the EFF's article on NSLs, and why every US-based service can't be trusted.
The data signal gives to state governments, is likely different from the info it gives to the federal goverment.
Signal also has an especially sus history.
Very resourceful links! Thanks! I wasn't doubting there are issues regarding Signal, especially considering its ties to the US, as I saw a video regarding its controversies. My point I wanted to make is there is no 100% secure application, and there will be bugs and vulnerabilities among applications we think we can trust. I believe Signal is still a major improvement regarding security, at least compared to Discord, but I would prefer XMPP, Matrix, etc. if I had the choice. Though I understand if an encrypted system is compromised, it's just as a good as being unencrypted, so if it turns out the US is getting sufficient information from Signal through a backdoor and the subpoena I mentioned was just for show, I hope PSL would consider migrating to Matrix or something more trustworthy. Then again, when the going gets tough, we may have to abandon our phones and electronics to stay safe and find ways to make revolutionary change under a police state.
For sure, and thank you for doing this work for your branch. Enough people need to push for the use of more secure platforms, (esp getting off google), and I hope that eventually becomes a mandatory directive, not just for PSL, but all parties.