I agree with everyone who likes the old face better, but I think everyone is forgetting the very public debacle with Elliot Page over this design. (Article is from before he transitioned and misgenders him.) Basically, the design was pretty obviously inspired by his performance/appearance in Juno to the point where a huge number of fans assumed he was involved.

People also gave him a lot of shit for being upset, and I remember a lot of people claiming he was bitter since the game he was actually starring in, Beyond Two Souls, was less well received. Naughty Dog is probably more aware of the potential legal trouble since Page’s comments on not wanting his likeness in the game are now pre-development/release.