They understand pretty well what it means to be human - they are fundamentally human in their essence, they just don't know much about the history of humans as it was lost to time
I don't think you can justify that they're human. Never wondered why there are millions of bottles, and drinks all over the place? It's explained as imitating the humans even though they don't even drink. All of the behaviour of most of the robots is just mega corrupted completely pointless actions that serve no purpose.
I mean, yeah, they can't drink and are just trying to imitate. But I think there is something more to it - in the ant village there is a robot that talks about he liked a smell and then caught himself and said something like "wait, I can't even smell". I think there is something to part of those behaviours being faint memories they kept and the rest being imitated as you said.
I'm inclined more towards the creative robots being formerly human. The ones that seem to be able to have independent thoughts and plan things, like the Outsiders who plan to escape the city. Or in your example, the creative painters.
I don't think the musician robot for example is a former human. They don't do creative work, they can only do copying from the music sheets and have played the same things for thousands of years.
They understand pretty well what it means to be human - they are fundamentally human in their essence, they just don't know much about the history of humans as it was lost to time
I don't think you can justify that they're human. Never wondered why there are millions of bottles, and drinks all over the place? It's explained as imitating the humans even though they don't even drink. All of the behaviour of most of the robots is just mega corrupted completely pointless actions that serve no purpose.
I mean, yeah, they can't drink and are just trying to imitate. But I think there is something more to it - in the ant village there is a robot that talks about he liked a smell and then caught himself and said something like "wait, I can't even smell". I think there is something to part of those behaviours being faint memories they kept and the rest being imitated as you said.
I do agree that some of them may be uploads.
I'm inclined more towards the creative robots being formerly human. The ones that seem to be able to have independent thoughts and plan things, like the Outsiders who plan to escape the city. Or in your example, the creative painters.
I don't think the musician robot for example is a former human. They don't do creative work, they can only do copying from the music sheets and have played the same things for thousands of years.