Josh Michelson responds to David Saks’ (writing for the South African Jewish Board of Deputies) February 2024 critique of the SAJFP and anti-Zionist Jews in general. The inadequacy of the SAJBD’s analysis and its deceptive premises are demonstrated. The duplicity is situated in the broader context of Zionism’s disinformation strategy. It is argued that the type of rhetoric Saks employs endangers not only Palestinians but Jews around the world.