Putting this in writing because, at heart, this is a writing issue for me.

I'm reading a story about a man who's portrayed as this super compassionate person when he nurses a goat back to health and in between chapters he's hungrily eating lamb stew. Like do you know where that comes from?

It's really annoying because it's just so jarring. I'm not saying that you can't be a good person while eating meat, but I wish it wasn't that thoughtles. It's a trope that's frustratingly common.

One of the most famous examples is Steven Universe. I try to go easy on the character, given his youth and upbringing, but the writers should have addressed it. I won't expect veganism right off the bat, but it felt strange that his thoughts on eating meat didn't come up any time he ate meat. And eating meat shows up in several plot-intensive scenes. It's a shame too because he's a half human and half alien that doesn't need to eat. And the plot features themes of oppression and imperialism.

I just wish character writing wasn't so bad sometimes. Just give your main character a different trait if you want to describe eating meat. It's not that hard, is it?

-edit: I'm not trying to spark another struggle session, I just hate seeing character disconnects like that where it's not even brought up. It's legit just bad writing. You can have a protagonist eat meat and still have a good person.

The particular story I was reading featured a contemporary adult temporarily living at a farm. He cares about particular animals there but the author makes a fumble by not even drawing a connection between the goat he befriends and the ones he eats. If his personality wasn't such a Mary Sue, and the author didn't mention it every five pages, I could've ignored the dissonance.

  • sootlion [any]
    ·
    2 years ago

    Uh, yes it does? Unless Plants and Bacteria are somehow not an 'arbitrary species line'.

    • Lord_ofThe_FLIES [he/him]
      ·
      2 years ago

      it's not arbitrary, are you telling me you can't see the difference? Which ones have the capacity of feeling joy, pain, emotion? Fuck off carnist

      • sootlion [any]
        ·
        edit-2
        2 years ago

        I can absolutely see the difference, but I very genuinely don't understand why it's not arbitrary. Why does a capacity for emotion endow a greater right to life?

        • robot_dog_with_gun [they/them]
          ·
          2 years ago

          easier to personify things we project emotion onto, but as a dirty carnist i think the brain functions we should care about for drawing the line are more complicated.