...so I'm gonna tell you something here instead.

I think a future communist society would have more nomads. For the bulk of humanity's existence, nomadic life was the norm. Property and contractual obligation has made settled life mandatory in most of the imperial core, with a slim handful of exceptions.

Here in the states, the contradiction is mind-boggling. We're told the settlement of America was necessary to the establishment of freedoms, that nobody else enjoys as much liberties as we do today. And yet, for those "liberties", we had to stop people from leading nomadic lives. Corralled and marched people miles, so they could be free. Stole babes from families, so they could be free. Free to do what, exactly?

Centuries ago, nomadic life was a fundamental freedom for millions. Maybe it could be again...

~

...not that I know what that nomadic life would look like, or how it would interplay with settled life... just that it seems like something that should be striven for

  • kristina [she/her]
    ·
    edit-2
    2 年前

    yeah it isnt. fishing and limited cultivation + the dangers of entering a new biome, knowing absolutely nothing about it, were huge deterrents

    mass migrations were mostly from huge disasters and overpopulation leading to depleted resources, and even then it wasnt a quick migration. the bantu migration for instance took nearly 1000 years, and the germanic migrations took nearly 400 years

    even the idea of the mongolian nomadic tribe is mostly incorrect. they had many permanent areas and just used the steppe for grazing and brought the herds back to those areas when it was time for slaughter. and prior to animal husbandry, steppe life was nonexistent. animal husbandry was probably first conceived around 13,000 bc. modern humans have been around since 250,000 years ago

    not to say it isnt a valid lifestyle, but the idea of it being the 'natural order' is likely incorrect. the natural order is probably camping out next to lake victoria while eating hallucinogenic berry bushes and fishing all year round

    • JoeByeThen [he/him, they/them]
      ·
      2 年前

      . the natural order is probably camping out next to lake victoria while eating hallucinogenic berry bushes and fishing all year round

      This is what they took from us.

    • TillieNeuen [she/her]
      ·
      edit-2
      2 年前

      And transhumance was pretty much always based around seasonal moves with flocks and herds, so since I don't expect pastoralism to be a major way of life in our communist future, I don't think transhumance is going to be a major way of life either.