• newacctidk [none/use name]
    ·
    23 days ago

    How are the Vong stand-ins for Arabs? Unless you mean thr Outbound Flight retcon which is Zahn being a clean Wehrmacht weirdo in his own little corner. The Palpatine was building the death star to fight the vong thing was implied in one source book by an idiot, and thankfully was fully dismissed by everyone else. Not that you didn't have fascist ass writers like Karen Travis, but I wouldn't say it was a common thing. Just don't let her near star wars again

    • UlyssesT
      ·
      edit-2
      8 days ago

      deleted by creator

      • newacctidk [none/use name]
        ·
        22 days ago

        Keep in mind NJO started before 9/11. Star By Star came out a month after 9/11, and the series wrapped at the US invaded Iraq. I don't think considering when it was written is great evidence. Yes the Saddam gassing the Kurds stuff already happened, but it wasn't much of the zeitgeist. NJO was plotted well in advance and most books finished their first drafts before the US was in Afghanistan.

        Not to say american neoliberal militarism was not an influence, but the Vong are honestly a less egregious example as things go. The EU of that era had that horrid trend of military characters always being right and for dramatic tension they have to defy orders. I love the X-wing series but they do that shit every fucking novel.

        Outbound Flight overshadows any influence on the Vong for me because unlike the Vong, the events of that story actually do come right out and try to justify military intervention and have the enemy "use human shields", with Zahn literally saying it let him write about Iraq without saying "Iraq"

        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SfBC6c_0YWw

        There are certainly liberal western biases to the entire Vong plot, particularly creating an invading enemy to defeat while writing yourselves a way to see reasonable and benevolent, in this case not using the bioweapon. I just don't think the Vong storyline should be lumped in with the one-off retcon implication that Palpy was "protecting the galaxy from the Vong"