hello comrades here we shall be discussing The Wretched of the earth preface and chapter one On Violence i was gonna write my own summry for yall but this summary and analysis i found would serve you all better than what I could write this morning, my sincere apoligies I wiil start us off with some optional question promts!

what did you think of satare's preface?

what does Fanon mean by "replacing one species with another"?

who is the colonized intellectual? what role does he serve?

what does Fanon say about nationalist reformist movements? what are their failings?

why must decolonization be total and all encompassing?

why is the allocation of instruments of force important? I also want to encourage everyone to try to make critique of the reading.

these are just a few things to get the ball rolling, please let me know what I can do better! Please keep commenting and contributing to this thread through out the week for those of you not caught up, this isnt school there is no late work, in fact i hope people come back to these threads many times to see other comrades thoughts. lastly it seems like you guys really like the summary and study guide I found so I will keep using it in future post (its pretty cool its like sparknotes)

English translation by Richard Philcox – https://ia801708.us.archive.org/3/items/the-wretched-of-the-earth/The Wretched Of The Earth.pdf – you'd be reading from page 42 to 311 of this PDF, 270 pages

English translation by Constance Farrington – https://abahlali.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/Frantz-Fanon-The-Wretched-of-the-Earth-1965.pdf

Original French text – https://monoskop.org/images/9/9d/Fanon_Frantz_Les_damnés_de_la_terre_2002.pdf

English audio version – https://inv.tux.pizza/playlist?list=PLZ_8DduHfUd2r1OOCtKh0M6Q9xD5RaR3S – about 12h20m – Alternative links
  • plantifa [they/them]
    ·
    edit-2
    11 months ago

    Thank you!

    Reading, even with the cursory analysis I had, through Fanon's writing is a breath of fresh air, especially through his viewpoint as a PoC intellectual from Martinique [which upon looking up, is a French "Single territorial collectivity" to this day. 🔥 🇫🇷 🔥 Free Martinique!'] without the biases and chauvinism, conscious and unconscious, of white western theoreticians.

    Striking is his affirmation that the act of decolonization is violent and can only be violent similarly to how colonialism and its establishment can only be violent, and that hand-wringing by the moderate liberals who equivocate the violence by colonized with violence by the colonizer, who go over the talking points of "Yes I believe colonialism is a monstrous system and I denounce it, yet violence committed in the sake of colonialism's opposition is also wrong! Change must be moderate, reserved, blah blah blah blah blah" ultimately are either cynical liars, or useful fools who will denounce the forceful response to colonialism/neocolonialism by the oppressed and exploited, and in the same breath, without any shame, excuse colonial violence as "a horrid thing, one to be opposed, but a regretful thing of the past, one that we can learn from" while turning a blind eye or denial of existing, ongoing oppression and expropriation of natural resources of colonies and neocolonies.

    He puts into words one of the things that infuriates me beyond measure when talking to the "white moderate" about imperialism, no matter how moralistically self-flagellating even the most well-meaning liberal is regarding imperialism, denying neocolonialism as an ongoing phenomena or relegating colonialism and the scars it had created as a 'thing of the past' and that 'we [blech, what do you mean WE] learned from our mistakes' and proceeding to uncritically absorb international "unbiased" news media or take government officials at face value perpetuating the same systems but under a new neocolonialist patina, which manufactures consent for punitive acts of military intervention or economic sanctions, makes apparent how it's the same shit but just a little bit different and these "mistakes" are still continuing to be made. The West has not changed, it will not change, and it cannot be trusted to bring about change for the dismantling of the successor systems of historical colonialism.

    His analysis that decolonization must be undertaken bottom up, and address both base and superstructure is an excellent point. It's apparent how decolonization of the base, of both means and relations of production, are critically important, but also with his point on how ignoring decolonization of the superstructure, of colonizer ideology, perpetuates a more decentralized system of compradors and vendepatrias that maintain oppressive systems.

    I meant to get around reading Wretched of the Earth, and what better time to do so than right now with comrades on Hexbear. I'm really liking this so far, thanks for pushing for this as a collective analysis on my favorite six-sided bear site.

    • Othello [comrade/them, love/loves]
      hexagon
      ·
      edit-2
      11 months ago

      for someone who claims to be busy, you sure have a great understanding of Fanons work !! I find reading fanons work to be both soothing and invigorating. soothing because he so clearly rejects this perverted morality that tells us the suffering and death brought on my colonialism is natural and just. and invigorating because he lays out the path forward with an sense of self-assuredness that makes me wanna {redacted}. I feel the same way when talking to white moderates, capitalist posing as compassionates be offending me, as kendrick says lol.

      but also with his point on how ignoring decolonization of the superstructure, of colonizer ideology, perpetuates a more decentralized system of compradors and vendepatrias that maintain oppressive systems

      I think this is one of there more important take aways, Ive really struggled to articulate this concept myself, how the colonizer can both leave and stay at the same time.

      Im so glad you are enjoying this discussion! Dont forget that deadlines are not real here and you can take your time with responses. you have great insight and add so much to the discussion plantifa!

      • plantifa [they/them]
        ·
        11 months ago

        Thank you! I'm looking forward to future discussion posts, thanks again for putting this together Othello! rat-salute-2

        • Othello [comrade/them, love/loves]
          hexagon
          ·
          11 months ago

          excited to see you there. and I cant take too much credit @vampire (i forgot how to tag people on here) is the one who got this started. I only hope im doing right by them!

          • plantifa [they/them]
            ·
            11 months ago

            Leading the discourse, providing discussion questions, and taking the time to respond to other poster's analyses is very important too, and on the second thing, you absolutely are, I'm enjoying the discussions!