By the marxist definition of the state, they are a state.
Rojava, and many anarchists, aren't marxists, so I don't think they'd care much about marxist definitions.
The fact is, anarchism is very diverse in its values and goals, and many anarchists disagree about what is and is not "real" anarchism. In my opinion, gatekeeping anarchism is pretty lame.
deleted by creator
Like this American anarchist? Rojava is inspired in part by American anarchism.
Rojava, and many anarchists, aren't marxists, so I don't think they'd care much about marxist definitions.
The fact is, anarchism is very diverse in its values and goals, and many anarchists disagree about what is and is not "real" anarchism. In my opinion, gatekeeping anarchism is pretty lame.
deleted by creator
I think this is wishful thinking, but as ong as you see Rojava as a success, i won't argue,