Elder Scrolls is literally the least "fash" fantasy out there. Yes, I am a huge fucking nerd, no I am not white, I'll see you in the comments mother fucker, I KNOW THE LORE! FIGHT ME!

  • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
    hexagon
    ·
    4 years ago

    This doesn't really work, because you can't just get these characters in a round robin 1v1 tournament without breaking the lore (timelines, getting HoK out of oblivion) so doing a lore analysis is kinda moot. but I guess if we are talking pre-apotheosis HoK, and we just time travel everyone into a pocket realm of oblivion, The Eternal Champion, the Hero of Kavatch and The Agent just get wiped instantly by the LBD's thuum and the Neravarine's artifacts (keening, sunder, and wraithguard), as they are just mortals who did a thing. Between the LBD and Neravarine, I would say the LBD comes out on top, simply due to the fact that the LBD has bend will wich can mind control even Dragons, which are some of the most powerfull non-deity status beings in the universe.

    • Zo1db3rg [comrade/them]
      ·
      4 years ago

      Unless HoK gets off a lucky wabbajack right out the gate while LDB is preparing the shout. Now I need to know which attack takes longer.

      • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
        ·
        4 years ago

        Wabbajack is probably faster than 3 word shout. 1 word shout is probably faster than wabbajack.

        • Zo1db3rg [comrade/them]
          ·
          4 years ago

          IMO I think wabbajack wins then. Is there a single word shout that could instantly render the HoK out of the fight? Cause if not then it's over for LDB. Even if they single shouts anything to interrupt the HoK he now has a cool down for the next shout. HoK just need to be able to smack them with one good wabbajack and it's over.

          • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
            ·
            4 years ago

            Perhaps not render HoK out of the fight, but can protect LDB from wabbajack itself. Slow time and Become Ethereal can at least negate the initial wabbajack.

            • Zo1db3rg [comrade/them]
              ·
              4 years ago

              True I guess but those are just temporary and the cool down would take long enough that as soon as the effects wear off it's wabba time. Sure LDB might get off one or two free hits but if we are talking about a fully geared and leveled HoK, it would take more than a couple of hits to take them out. In the meantime the second those effects wear off it's game over.

    • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
      ·
      4 years ago

      So let's say that someone used an elder scroll in each timeline and every hero were transported to Sovngarde, you would give the win to HoK because the lore describes his feats as greater than every other hero?

      • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
        hexagon
        ·
        4 years ago

        Neravarine has the most feats (killed multiple god-level entities) but feats don't equal power, the ) LBD would win through bend will alone.

          • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
            hexagon
            ·
            4 years ago

            The protagonists don't have a set playstyle, for obvious reasons, all we do know is the the Neravarine has the Tools of Kagranak, wich makes them super power full in many ways, and that they killed living gods with them.

            • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
              ·
              4 years ago

              I mean we know that absent anything else, the LDB at least has the Thu'um. Do any of the others have a default power set?

              • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
                hexagon
                ·
                4 years ago

                No, all the protagonists are just some person with powerful artifacts and some way of fighting, with the exception of the LDB, who is not just a person, but an actual dragon.

                  • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
                    hexagon
                    ·
                    4 years ago

                    To be a dragon is to be a pice of the Aka-oversoul (alduin, akatosh, auri-el, all lesser dragons) and the LBD does not have the soul of a man or mer or beast, but the soul of a dragon.

                    • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
                      ·
                      4 years ago

                      Source? Where is this stated that the soul of a dragon is equivalent to a dragon? Azura's star might contain a giant's soul. Does that mean that Azura's star is a giant? No, it means that Azura's star is a daedric artifact which houses a giant's soul and not a giant itself.

                      • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
                        hexagon
                        ·
                        4 years ago

                        Me calling the LBD a literal dragon is just something I like to do, idk any in game source that does this.

                        • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
                          ·
                          4 years ago

                          So why would the dragon aspect shout exist then? Doesn't the existence of the shout show a divide between the LDB and a dragon? Same for dragonrend. Apparently no dragon can actually use dragonrend.

                          • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
                            hexagon
                            ·
                            4 years ago

                            Obviously there is a divide, the LBD has a mortal body, instead of a dragon body, wich allows them to comprehend mortality and use dragonrend and such, while also having its obvious drawbacks. I am of the belief that the "soul" as it exists in TES is what makes somebody who they are, not the body, and to some extent in real life as well. :thonk-trans:

                            • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
                              ·
                              4 years ago

                              Why are you of this opinion? What have you read in the lore that would lead you to the conclusion that the soul is the totality of a thing?

                              • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
                                hexagon
                                ·
                                4 years ago

                                Idk if you noticed but like half the appeal of TES lore is the openness of the community/creators of the lore to just fill in the gaps with you own headcannon, I literally don't care about what is 100% cannon or not, if you do, that's cool, if your headcannon is different, thats cool too, mine is just better.

                                • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
                                  ·
                                  edit-2
                                  4 years ago

                                  I mean I get the headcanon part when it comes to fleshing out a particular player character, like whether or not they use bows. Isn't this supposed to be a technical thing in-universe?

                                  • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
                                    hexagon
                                    ·
                                    4 years ago

                                    We have to remember that there is no objective source of lore in TES. All the in game texts are written by an in universe person, so questions like "are dragonborns dragons" would be a debate in universe as well, so... Just headcannon it, its fun.

                                    • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
                                      ·
                                      4 years ago

                                      Isn't what is not objective stuff like: whether the LDB became the Archmage of Winterhold, or became the leader of the companions? Stuff like the existence of Altmer, the LDB beating Alduin are 100% objective, no?

                                      • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
                                        hexagon
                                        ·
                                        4 years ago

                                        Not really. The games are just representations of the actual TES universe, weather the protagonists did particular quests, what race and gender they were, is left vague. Like obviously whiterun isn't 15 huts in universe, 90% of the population isnt bandits, and so on.

                                        • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
                                          ·
                                          4 years ago

                                          Stuff like the existence of Altmer, the LDB beating Alduin are 100% objective, no?

                                          Are the existence of high elves not objective?

                                          • CrookedSerpent [she/her]
                                            hexagon
                                            ·
                                            4 years ago

                                            In a sense, no, just as we could say the existence of birds is not 100% a given IRL. But, for the sake of communication, in real life and in TES it is safe to make assumptions about such things. But really, if you really care about 100% canonical constancy, than TES probably isn't for you.

                                            • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
                                              ·
                                              4 years ago

                                              I don't care about 100% consistency; I've admitted that stuff like Archmage of Winterhold is left up in the air. There has to be a baseline consistency though, otherwise the universe would just be a nonsensical mess.

                                                • TeethOrCoat [none/use name]
                                                  ·
                                                  4 years ago

                                                  Earlier you said to another commenter:

                                                  No, the dunmer’s skin was turned to ash (blueish-gray, and thier original skin color was gold-brown) for the tribunal’s betrayal of Azura at red Mountain (a volcano). Azura’s actions are not good (she is known for being venguful when slighted), the deities of TES are not the arbiters of morality in this universe, this is not in anyway an association of black skin with evil.

                                                  The elder scrolls universe isn't a nonsensical mess because a certain baseline consistency is established. We both believe the dunmer exist, we both believe deities are not the arbiters of morality in the universe, we both acknowledge that dragonrend cannot be used by dragons. Even the soul as dragon thing you believe in is at least metaphorically sound. We aren't sitting here claiming that Nazeem single-handedly defeated Alduin at the Soul Cairn because such a claim would be so far off the base establishment.