Have ya'll ever met eugenicists and racists? those are some of the most natalist motherfuckers out there. You think all the mystic woo woo "having children is like +1 good" bullshit you want, THOSE PEOPLE THINK THAT HARDER THAN YOU DO!!!
This rant is sponsored by yesterday's grandma demanding in the form of a question when I'm going to shit out babies for her and also random strawman comments in an obscure subreddit.
Edit: ITT: people actually starting to bully me for not wanting to have kids. Did not expect this on "leftist" website.
Yes, they're different, but the latter doesn't exist in any serious capacity. There are no groups of people practically trying to express anti-natalism as a sterilize everything movement.
For the vast majority, this is somewhere between a thought exercise and a gentle plea to others to consider not having kids. Not disabled others, or poor others, but any others.
There was one user here with a long established post history who did argue to the point of a temporary ban (so I won't name the name) that no one should reproduce, and no animal for that matter, until and unless some magical means to determine consent for the unborn before they were born could be established. That was their absolutist position, and may well effectively be a sterilization mandate as a nihilistic power fantasy.
The thing about materialism is that it's trying to describe the way the world the way it is, and why it is that way, and what we can do to achieve a better future. It's inherently political.
Theres no practical way to even pursue the goal of sterilising everything. It's purely a moral philosophy with no possible praxis. There's no way to build a political movement out of this. When people here talk about natalism, they seem to want to believe it's motivating people into action, but how could it? It's lile believing everybody should be able to summon portals --A cool thought, but at the end of the day, an idea that doesn't exist on any political spectrum.
That particular user with the "nothing should ever be born again" take was terminal-stage idealistic about a nihilistic proposition. I didn't even know how to respond except by posting this comic.
Whatever caused you to post this comic thank you 😂😂
Which is the issue. It can’t really be acted on except as bastardizations of the idea that end up hurting people.