A lot of traditionally "good" students will complain about open book exams though, since the questions generally tend to require you to go beyond the rote text book ones.
For instance, in 1st year phys the final tutorial question was open book, gave you an extra possible 5% above 100% and was simply "calculate the total power output per year of Wolf 359." A full third of the class complained it was an unfair question.
A lot of traditionally "good" students will complain about open book exams though, since the questions generally tend to require you to go beyond the rote text book ones.
For instance, in 1st year phys the final tutorial question was open book, gave you an extra possible 5% above 100% and was simply "calculate the total power output per year of Wolf 359." A full third of the class complained it was an unfair question.