Holy shit, every time I'm reminded of this book and film franchise just everything about it just fills me with absolute white-hot hate. I feel like someone superglued They Live sunglasses to my head; every single person involved in writing, filming and promoting of this filth, and their circle of family and friends, gets cultural revolutioned the moment I find a way to resurrect Mao.

:agony-limitless:

  • CriticalOtaku [he/him]
    ·
    3 years ago

    So... here's the thing about CRA- the guy that wrote it only lived in Singapore till he was like 12 or something before his rich family moved to the States. That said, he wrote what he knew, which was about the kind of strange pathologies only the super-rich acquire, and along with that the culture shock of being an immigrant and the struggles on squaring that identity with your original identity back home (altho, obviously this plays less of a role in the book as Joel points out, since the book is more obviously centered around a class based Cinderella story).

    What that means is that the picture he paints of Singapore is really really skewed- for one, it's 30 years out of date, and (as every Singaporean will tell you) Singapore is a lot more diverse than as portrayed in the film. In his defense, he only claims to be writing about the tiny slice of the population in the title (effectively, the 1%) and he does have some kinda/sorta interesting things to say about racism in the follow-up books with some of the secondary characters, but that's obviously not in the movie.

    What the movie is, is a Liberal Immigrant Chinese power-fantasy- of a mythical homeland where Asians aren't the ones oppressed or subject to white power structures, but where they are the ones with all the power. It's a movie about being able to live in two worlds- of being able to inhabit a Western Liberal immigrant identity as a component of global capital, and of being able to use the supposed "superior" qualities of progressive liberalism to seamlessly leverage and transition back into a place of true belonging, to return to the homeland as a beacon of modernity against stodgy Conservatism (as embodied by Michelle Yeoh's character, who really deserved better).

    There was nothing more infuriating than reading the discourse after the movie came out, where a lot of Asian diaspora who were celebrating the film for it's all Asian cast as a landmark cultural moment (and rightly so, I think, even tho such things do ring hollow under neo-liberalism) hijacked leftist terminology to defend/deflect against very real criticism from South East Asians who took umbrage with our portrayal in the movie. Which I think spoke to the underlying reason for the movies existence, and who it's really for- there's a reason the movie opens with a quote about China and it's awakening shaking the world, after all.