so I dunno if it’d be a good idea to present yourself as supernatural
You can completely hide this easily. Just write down "X was assassinated by a verifiable member/enthusiast of Y" then pick one (or mix and match): DSA/4rth International/Black Hammer/QAnon/kekistan. FBI will be too busy investigating your strawman group and looking for secret discord chatrooms that don't exists to presume there is something supernatural.
You can completely hide this easily. Just write down "X was assassinated by a verifiable member/enthusiast of Y" then pick one (or mix and match): DSA/4rth International/Black Hammer/QAnon/kekistan. FBI will be too busy investigating your strawman group and looking for secret discord chatrooms that don't exists to presume there is something supernatural.
Looks like the intelligence services are about to have a secret hot civil war