I've been refining my take after reading some interpretation and explanations and this is final take:
Not every book will or should be for a white audience. It should cater to whoever they want. But the tweet also also seems to assume that every non white person has sufficient knowledge of their own culture to understand everything being written. Of course maybe that kind of person is not the intended audience which is also fine, but it's a bit alienating to be told that you're not entitled to learn about your own culture just because some random :lmayo: might benefit from a free translation
And no, this is not written by some mad white guy who doesn't understand what shawarma means. It's coming from an Asian immigrant who's far removed from his culture with little resources in English to learn about it.
I write on Chinese cultural shit for a majority-white and extremely Eurocentric academic field. Explaining every basic thing every single fucking time is indeed rather tiring. I don’t know what the context of her rant is, but I sort of see where she’s coming from. I mean yeah, when I intentionally use untranslated words/concepts, it’s typically so the reader has to realize that they need to do their part in learning new concepts and new ways of thinking/living in the world, rather than thinking everything can ultimately be translated/assimilated into the anglophone world they are already familiar with. So I guess it isn’t/shouldn’t be about shutting the reader out but rather asking them to think differently if they are willing.
Edit: I should add that, I think this problem arises from having to write to a PMC readership, where you have to write to an imagined reader who has zero material connections with you other than through the market of sales and citations.
Broke: Not translating "yi" as "righteousness" because the use of "yi" in ancient Chinese text is contextual and has no good English equivalent.
Woke: Not translating "yi" as "righteousness" because "yi" is shorter to type than "righteousness."
deleted by creator
deleted by creator