that isn't really a charitable interpretation of what i said lol
what i meant to convey is that trying to explain the fact that americans don't speak other languages solely with the fact that they don't have the means to doesn't really stick when it's objectively one of the better countries in the world to live in, despite how god awful it still is. it's not like the rest of the world live more comfortable lives.
Look, there are two material reasons why Americans don't often learn other languages. The first is that they usually don't need to: English is the most widely spoken language in the world. People from poorer countries might have to have more than one language for one reason or another just to get by.
The second goes to what you're saying about comfortable lives: yes, Americans are more comfortable in many ways than most other people. But they don't enjoy the kind of social-democratic benefits that Europeans typically enjoy, which means they often don't have the time to learn other skills or travel internationally like Europeans do. It's hard to find the time to learn a language or experience another culture when your government doesn't mandate paid leave.
Anyway, this shit is so petty. I just don't understand why self-described communists would ever make fun of millions of people for a lack of education in a foreign language. That's the kind of shit liberals do.
i'm not making fun of Americans for not speaking another language. i'm at most critiquing and poking fun at american culture. speaking other languages isn't just knowledge, it's a door for a deeper understanding of other cultures and peoples. americans being monolingual is also a reflection of american exceptionalism and the disdain of the Other.
this isn't a phenomenon that is exclusive to working class people, even wealthy americans or americans traveling abroad won't know a lick of another language. not sure why the comparison to europe. again, i'm not comparing America to other NATO or OECD countries, i'm comparing it globally.
i do agree this is petty and i'm not sure why a lot of people are treating this as some sort of personal slight when it is not. i'm not moralizing being monolingual, i just disagree with the view that american monolingualism is only due to economic factors and somehow neatly separated and insulated from american culture, which people on this site have no trouble critiquing and poking fun at, for instance.
that isn't really a charitable interpretation of what i said lol
what i meant to convey is that trying to explain the fact that americans don't speak other languages solely with the fact that they don't have the means to doesn't really stick when it's objectively one of the better countries in the world to live in, despite how god awful it still is. it's not like the rest of the world live more comfortable lives.
Look, there are two material reasons why Americans don't often learn other languages. The first is that they usually don't need to: English is the most widely spoken language in the world. People from poorer countries might have to have more than one language for one reason or another just to get by.
The second goes to what you're saying about comfortable lives: yes, Americans are more comfortable in many ways than most other people. But they don't enjoy the kind of social-democratic benefits that Europeans typically enjoy, which means they often don't have the time to learn other skills or travel internationally like Europeans do. It's hard to find the time to learn a language or experience another culture when your government doesn't mandate paid leave.
Anyway, this shit is so petty. I just don't understand why self-described communists would ever make fun of millions of people for a lack of education in a foreign language. That's the kind of shit liberals do.
i'm not making fun of Americans for not speaking another language. i'm at most critiquing and poking fun at american culture. speaking other languages isn't just knowledge, it's a door for a deeper understanding of other cultures and peoples. americans being monolingual is also a reflection of american exceptionalism and the disdain of the Other.
this isn't a phenomenon that is exclusive to working class people, even wealthy americans or americans traveling abroad won't know a lick of another language. not sure why the comparison to europe. again, i'm not comparing America to other NATO or OECD countries, i'm comparing it globally.
i do agree this is petty and i'm not sure why a lot of people are treating this as some sort of personal slight when it is not. i'm not moralizing being monolingual, i just disagree with the view that american monolingualism is only due to economic factors and somehow neatly separated and insulated from american culture, which people on this site have no trouble critiquing and poking fun at, for instance.