Tryna start bringing lunch into the office instead of buying a sandwich every day and I figure I might as well try to make it vegan if I can

Death to America

  • StewartCopelandsDad [he/him]
    ·
    2 years ago

    mentions nothing about soak or lectin content, tbh this was the worst source

    The text specifies that these beans were soaked.

    idk what this is but google indicates it’s a pressure cooker thing which, again, uses higher temperatures than are otherwise possible

    Nothing to do with pressure cookers, it's the modern name for "quick soak" described in that article. As seen here, here. Some people are doing the same thing with an instant pot, bringing it to a boil and then letting it sit. You don't need to soak beans before boiling as long as they're fully cooked.

    People get sick from lectin because they cook at insufficient temperatures, not because they skip the soak. Source:

    In seven of the incidents the beans were soaked prior to cooking, although in one instance for 3 h only (episode 3) and the subsequent cooking periods varied. In two instances the beans were soaked but not cooked prior to consumption (episodes 5 and 6). In only one incident was it stated that the beans were boiled (episode 2).

    • AmericaDelendeEst [any]
      ·
      edit-2
      2 years ago

      The text specifies that these beans were soaked

      Oh my fucking god, yes, I know, and you don't, you specifically avoid mentioning it

      haven’t tried the “Quick Soaking Beans or Power Soak” method yet. But basically, just bring a pot of water to boil, add your beans, and then let them boil for about three minutes. After boiling, remove the beans from the stove and let them sit in the hot water for 2-6 hours. This method apparently removes 80 percent of complex bean sugars. How does that toot your horn?

      Lmao literally advises 2-6 hour soak despite PoWeR sOaKiNg

      People get sick from lectin because they cook at insufficient temperatures, not because they skip the soak. Source:

      I'm going to go with the multiple sources you literally yourself cited indicating the need for a soak instead of just telling people "yea brah just cook them 10 minutes"

      Also

      In only one incident was it stated that the beans were boiled (episode 2).

      Wow fam looks like that boiling temp really does the job 100%

      Have fun getting people sick

      • StewartCopelandsDad [he/him]
        ·
        2 years ago

        Graph in soybean source shows this is heavily temperature dependent.

        mentions nothing about soak or lectin content, tbh this was the worst source

        The text specifies that these beans were soaked.

        Oh my fucking god, yes, I know, and you don’t, you specifically avoid mentioning it

        I relied on this source specifically and only for this graph shape and did not "specifically avoid" the fact that it was about soaked soybeans. Why would soaking overnight radically change the shape of temp-time curve? The graph will look similar for same aqueous reaction in unsoaked kidney beans.

        The "power soak" thing is the same as the LA Times author did: bring to a boil, let sit one hour. Bon Appetit appears to have coined the phrase, so take their definition as authoritative since you are not familiar with it firsthand. I defined the term so you know what I mean; don't play Reddit semantics games.

        I see no evidence of people boiling unsoaked kidney beans until palatable (~2h) and getting sick, and plenty of evidence of people doing that and not getting sick. So we have an upper bound. For unsoaked beans, the 15 minute cook time for lectin deactivation in soaked beans is a lower bound. Because quick soaking (15m additional water time) is effective, I think the lectin deactivation time in unsoaked kidney beans is probably below the 30 minute mark at 100C, far faster than the beans soften. What do you think the lectin deactivation time in unsoaked kidney beans is? If you think it's something stupid, I will happily eat a couple hard-ass unsoaked kidney beans at the 30m mark if you promise to apologize when I don't get sick. You reason like you're still drunk.

        • AmericaDelendeEst [any]
          ·
          2 years ago

          I relied on this source specifically and only for this graph shape and did not “specifically avoid” the fact that it was about soaked soybeans

          you specifically avoid mentioning soaking beans at all, for some weird fucking reason, despite citing scientific studies which explicitly indicate pre soaking the beans to achieve the lectin deactiviation time tables you are stating

          Why would soaking overnight radically change the shape of temp-time curve?

          Why would your own sources continue to soak them if it were entirely unnecessary

          The graph will look similar for same aqueous reaction in unsoaked kidney beans.

          k bro

          The “power soak” thing is the same as the LA Times author did: bring to a boil, let sit one hour

          wow sounds like it's still soaking hmm curious

          I see no evidence of people boiling unsoaked kidney beans until palatable (~2h) and getting sick

          beans were boiled, still got sick, your own source lmao

          15m additional water time

          weird how you literally state it as boil, soak for an hour plus, but now say "15m additional time"

          If you think it’s something stupid, I will happily eat a couple hard-ass unsoaked kidney beans at the 30m mark if you promise to apologize when I don’t get sick.

          have fun since you're literally ignoring all your own sources re: power soaking

          You reason like you’re still drunk.

          you reason like a dipshit and I wish you'd stop responding so I wouldn't be forced to see it because this site doesn't let me just block you or deactivate inbox response

          I'm done, ignoring your next response

          • StewartCopelandsDad [he/him]
            ·
            2 years ago

            Why would soaking overnight radically change the shape of temp-time curve?

            Why would your own sources continue to soak them if it were entirely unnecessary

            that's just how people cook beans, of course they test it that way. as you will learn from reading literally any recipe, soaking beans makes them softer.

            I see no evidence of people boiling unsoaked kidney beans until palatable (~2h) and getting sick

            beans were boiled, still got sick, your own source lmao

            You really think that this person boiled unsoaked beans for two hours and got sick? (a) that's not specified in the source and (b) why would beans take 15 minutes to be safe when soaked, but more than two hours when not soaked?

            15m additional water time

            weird how you literally state it as boil, soak for an hour plus, but now say “15m additional time”

            Per LA Times, if you cook black beans without soaking it takes two hours. If you quick soak, it takes 1 hour + 1h15m. 15m additional water time.

            Absolutely insane behavior. Eight pathetic line-split Redditor rebuttals but you're afraid to take a position on how long unsoaked kidney beans need to be cooked. Get it together man.

            • AmericaDelendeEst [any]
              ·
              edit-2
              2 years ago

              that’s just how people cook beans, of course they test it that way. as you will learn from reading literally any recipe, soaking beans makes them softer.

              lol k guy who forgot beans have lectins to begin with

              Per LA Times, if you cook black beans without soaking it takes two hours. If you quick soak, it takes 1 hour + 1h15m. 15m additional water time.

              all over the place with the damn beans, kidney beans have 30,000-70000 HAU of lectins, idk what black beans have but I guarantee it's significantly lower

              guess what, even fully fucking cooked kidney beans still have a lectin content of 200-400 HAU, in the range of entirely uncooked lentils, but go off believing it's all 100% destroyed by a 10 minute boil

              go off ignoring the fucking function of your power soak

              Absolutely insane behavior

              Eat my fucking asshole

                • AmericaDelendeEst [any]
                  ·
                  2 years ago

                  I told you, I'm fucking done you debate bro piece of shit, the fucking FDA literally recommends a 5 hour soak for raw kidney beans, to prevent illness, not for fucking palatability

                  Studies done by British scientists suggest that beans should be soaked in water for at least 5 hours, the water poured away, and the beans boiled in fresh water for at least 30 minutes

                  https://www.fda.gov/media/83271/download

                  If the massive amounts of lectins in kidney beans are fully deactivated by a 10 minute boil (the presence of 200-400 HAU in fully cooked beans should tell you that they fucking aren't) then why recommend throwing out the water? Just drink that shit up, you fucking moron

                  • StewartCopelandsDad [he/him]
                    ·
                    edit-2
                    2 years ago

                    How long do unsoaked kidney beans need to be cooked at 100C? Take a position, coward.

                    I’m done, ignoring your next response

                    you can't even commit to not replying. what do you do for fun, road rage?


                    bonus:

                    The syndrome usually is caused by ingestion of raw, soaked kidney beans, either alone or in salads or casseroles. Several outbreaks have been associated with beans cooked in slow cookers (i.e., countertop appliances that cook foods at low temperatures for several hours) or in casseroles that had not reached an internal temperature high enough to destroy the glycoprotein lectin.

                    Remember when I said "People get sick from lectin because they cook at insufficient temperatures, not because they skip the soak"?

                    • AmericaDelendeEst [any]
                      ·
                      2 years ago

                      the fda just recommends a 5 hour soak, specifically mentioning to throw away the water used, for no reason, just fun, just to make people waste water

                      power soak some beans and drink it hope it makes you shit yourself to death

                      • StewartCopelandsDad [he/him]
                        ·
                        2 years ago

                        are you drinking bean water normally? even from a can you drain and rinse lol.

                        How long do unsoaked kidney beans need to be cooked at 100C? Are you afraid to commit and be proven wrong? I've avoiding directly wishing you harm because I expect it's against site rules. I will not do it in this comment either. If you're right, pick a number and cause me harm irl. Otherwise go seethe somewhere else.