Annoyed by the critics that suddenly feel betrayed by the series because they had convinced themselves the games weren't sexist even when it couldn't have been more obvious. People tried to tell them Bayonetta was misogynist as fuck but they were dismissed as "sex-negative" or whatever.

  • GorbinOutOverHere [comrade/them]
    ·
    2 years ago

    I think the point is that bayonneta can be a man's horny fantasy and also a woman's horny fantasy too and the existence of said horny fantasy isn't inherently misogynist (although statements like "i think all women should dress like her" absolutely are) and saying that it is is a slight on women who enjoy said horny fantasy as well as those who might physically or stylistically relate to Bayonetta's aesthetic

    • ForgotMyLogInAgain [any]
      hexagon
      ·
      2 years ago

      A woman having the same fantasy doesn't mean it can't be misogynist. That kind of defense only comes up when women are into something that was designed with men as the intended target audience.

      These people didn't come to the defense of 50 shades of grey with the same argument. It was something everyone dunked on as sexist even though it was written for women by a woman.

      We live in a misogynist culture so it isn't rare for us to have misogynist fantasies.

      • GorbinOutOverHere [comrade/them]
        ·
        2 years ago

        okay, well, I've just seen this user repeatedly express their frustration with the attitudes that it is wrong for a woman to enjoy or appreciate these things and construe it as a form of bodyshaming when they relate their own aesthetic to what's being criticized and I don't think they deserve to be browbeaten into believing they're just internalizing misogyny or whatever just because that's what you feel to be correct about it

        • ForgotMyLogInAgain [any]
          hexagon
          ·
          2 years ago

          I didn't say they women wrong to enjoy these things. I don't think we should pretend misogynist media is something it's not.

          We all enjoy problematic things.

          • GorbinOutOverHere [comrade/them]
            ·
            edit-2
            2 years ago

            I mean saying a sexualized female character is inherently misogynistic is literally saying that women are wrong to enjoy that thing, it is an argument inherently framed that the woman enjoying those things is just naively enjoying a misogynist male fantasy and is stripped of her agency and ability to enjoy said thing, which is kind of fucked up when that thing is, to those women, related to "being sexual at all themselves"

            and saying Bayonetta is a misogynist thing because this dev guy said misogynistic things isn't a really good argument

            the things he said were misogynistic, the thing that was made with a small portion of his involvement (pretty sure like workers make things not just one dev guy btw) is not, especially not as a consequence of his saying or believing those things

            "blah blah blah the artist's intention" the Fahrenheit 451 guy said the book was about how bad TV is

            • ForgotMyLogInAgain [any]
              hexagon
              ·
              2 years ago

              Sexualized depiction women are inherently misogynist because we live in a patriarchal society and sexualization is distinct from sexuality. Watch the lingerie is not armor video.

              There are video games where women have nude sex scenes and they aren't sexualized and there are video games where women are clothed and doing something that has nothing to do with sex and are sexualized.

              Saying women who enjoy misogynist things is not an attack on them. Something can be misogynist and we can have complex feelings about it. It doesn't mean we are being tricked or have no say in how we process it. In one of the links I posted, a woman said Bayonetta was misogynist and she also talked about what she liked about the game.

              Your argument is essentially that if a woman enjoys a piece of media, it can't be sexist. That's a lib way of understanding things.

              The workers made the character under his direction. His ideas shaped the character. He isn't a capitalist, he's an artist, and a worker himself.

              This is your defense of Bayonetta:

              She and the game can't be misogynist because there are women that like the character and games

              The series creator, the director/writer (and another producer) of the game actually had little to do with its development (citation needed) so their misogynism regarding the development actually had no effect on the game. This also implies that all the other men that worked on the game weren't misogynist, which you somehow know.

              Ignoring feminist critics that called Bayonetta misogynist.

              That leads me to another question. Is there any popular art that you think is actually misogynist? Because if there's something that's enjoyed by millions of people worldwide, some of those people are going to be women which leads to popular art unable to be misogynist.

            • ForgotMyLogInAgain [any]
              hexagon
              ·
              2 years ago

              The other main contributor to the character is the original VA, who's outed herself as blue lives matter transphobic anti-choice chud. Character doesn't have a lot on her side.