See this for actually in-depth reviews
I've seen an above average amount of Episode 1s this time around.
This is good, go watch.
Heavenly Delusion
Mobile Suit Gundam: Witch from Mercury S2
Enjoyable
Yuri is my Job!
The Dangers in My Heart
Kawaisugi Crisis [a shitpost but endearingly so]
Otaku Elf [it has product placement :agony-shivering:]
Mid
KonoSuba: An Explosion on This Wonderful World! [tbh I never cared much for Megumin]
The Aristocrat's Otherworldly Adventure: Serving Gods Who Go Too Far [generic af]
My Love Story with Yamada-kun at Lv999
I hate the MC, but otherwise mid
I Got a Cheat Skill in Another World and Became Unrivaled in The Real World, Too [incel power fantasy]
Skip and Loafer [the MC gives off young conservative member vibes}
The Legendary Hero is Dead!
Awful - So Bad It's Good
KamiKatsu: Working for God in a Godless World [Hilarious Trainwreck, questionable views, quite horny]
Awful
My One-Hit Kill Sister [incest, horny, isekai]
Summoned to Another World for a Second Time [horrendously sexist MC and very boring. It was in fact the show that broke my resolve in watching most new releases.]
i watched ep 2 of Lv999 Yamada-kun and i think it might do better than mid before its done. i will admit to being a softie for the genre tho
EDIT:
two things i watched that didn't make it on your list
Jigokuraku - Hells Paradise - this is the big new shounen manga adaptation this year, and will most likely go many seasons. i haven't read the source so can't tell you much except that it's MAPPA, eps 1 and 2 make a good impression if you are into the gritty bloody type of shounen (and are pretty incredibly gory if you don't)
Mashle: Magic and Muscles - watched this on a whim. haven't read the source. in a world with magic the MC has none, but is instead incredibly strong. its got the standard plot; he's been hidden in the forest by his father because people without magic are weeded out, but you can't keep an incredibly strong guy out of trouble forever, run in with the authorities, ends up enrolled in magic school. melodrama, action plot, physical comedy. also, a cop gets humiliated a few times for comedic effect in ep1 so :carlin-pog: overall good first impression, will see where it goes. oh, and i have a sneaking suspicion that it is gearing up to be a satirical parody of harry potter lmao