I'm looking for specific and non obvious answers. Give me something visceral, rid the world of a figure or nation you hate. Preserve a culture you adore. It doesn't have to make sense either, you are basically god here.

What I mean is don't just say you'd get rid of imperialism or colonialism bc no shit

Personally I would make it so that the Americas are never discovered by the old world and every "would be" conquistador (especially cortez and pizarro) explodes.

  • ComradeSharkfucker@lemmy.ml
    hexagon
    ·
    edit-2
    2 months ago

    I was thinking more along the lines of two giant walls splitting the pacific and atlantic down the middle. The walls reach the stratosphere and if european touches them they explode.

    Your solution is good too but my goal is to see how they would develop in isolation. Its also worth mentioning that the new worlders had a severe disadvantage not just in knowledge but in resources. They did not have large pack animals so much of their labor power was tied up in manual tasks. They also had significantly less time to domesticate their plants making them more nutrient rich. Peas were already domesticated by the time they had even began farming iirc. Although the Inca's and pre Incan societies were very proficient at selective plant breeding. So while a thousand years of metallurgy would help I'm not sure it would be enough

    • HarryLime [any]
      ·
      edit-2
      2 months ago

      I mean, I don't want to take your joke too seriously or anything, but that's kind of anti-Marxist...

        • HarryLime [any]
          ·
          2 months ago

          Preventing contact between Eurasia and the Americas would significantly hamper human development, leading to a world without socialism or communism. Also, assuming that you'd do the wall to prevent the genocide of native Americans, there's the underlying assumption that any kind of contact would necessarily lead to genocide, which is an inherently right wing assumption (genocide and conquest = human nature).

          I know I'm overthinking a joke answer, but it's what it is.

          • ComradeSharkfucker@lemmy.ml
            hexagon
            ·
            edit-2
            2 months ago

            I know I'm overthinking a joke answer, but it's what it is.

            This is fair lol, I do it all the time no worries. Obviously I wouldn't actually do this if I had the power to but I am really mad about the spanish rn. Regardless, while I don't believe conquest is inherent to human nature, I find it hard to believe any other outcome was likely given the difference in power and systems in place. However despite that my biggest issue is disease. I don't want them meeting because it would be devastating for one group or the other no matter what. I am also very curious to see how society would have developed in the isolated Americas. I wonder how different and how similar they would have been to us.

            Also I am not sure how this would prevent communism long term. Sure it would slow things down but its shouldn't be impossible no?

            • HarryLime [any]
              ·
              2 months ago

              Fair enough I guesss

              Also I am not sure how this would prevent communism long term. Sure it would slow things down but its shouldn't be impossible no?

              You need a global economy, interconnected with lots of people spreading technology and ways of organizing and capital, et cetera.

              In fact, at a bare minimum, you probably need the potato to spread throughout the world. I don't think the economic and technological development for capitalism, and later to socialism, is possible without potatoes.