I'll start with what I assume is an unpopular opinion here: I am not convinced that the field of finance is 100% bullshit. Yes, we all know about the prominent current example of how markets can fail, but (a) note that, in principle, the market does have a mechanism to punish the people who do too much short-selling, even if the capitalist class isn't currently letting that mechanism do its job, and (b) in the long run, we all know Gamestop stock isn't going to be at a high price forever, and one way or another it will eventually fall to the price it "should" be. Most of the time, markets are okay, perhaps even, dare I say, GOOD, at aggregating information from a wide variety of sources about the value and scarcity of things.

I think that many of the things finance is supposed to do -- e.g. distributing risk over time and space, allocating resources to promising technologies, incentivizing people to make bets that contribute to aggregated predictions about the future of the economy -- are good things that a socialist economy would need to have a good replacement for. At the very least, I think there's a baby in the bathwater here.

So, considering the things that I associate with "finance" in the capitalist country I live in (e.g. stock markets, insurance, banking, venture capital) what alternatives have past and current socialist countries used?

  • LaBellaLotta [any]
    ·
    4 years ago

    Great question comrade! I always think about this because every socialist or communist economic system ever built has been under extreme economic pressures from the external hegemony of capitalist countries. That’s why I’ll always be an internationalist. I’m gonna read up on banking in China and get back to you!