"“Historian Michael Malet writes that at this time,“criminals entered the army for what they could get out of it, especially plunder in the towns.”
Excerpt From: Sean Patterson. “Makhno and Memory: Anarchist and Mennonite Narratives of Ukraine’s Civil War, 1917–1921.”
It's very much just denialism of Soviet success & idolizing what never "could've been" rather than accepting reality
We can't beatify Makhno and write hagiographies for a man who when:
"A delegation from Novozlatopol once went to Machno [sic] to discuss his raids against the Jews. Machno’s reply was “What can I do ? They’re just a bunch of ignorant peasants”, referring to his own men.”
There's been mistakes. Lenin should have cut a deal with Makhno.
no, Makhno should've been BTFO'd because his bands were doing pogroms & not assisting with the anti-imperialist war in the West
Lionizing Makhno is just comporting oneself with anti-communist Western Sovietology, not with the facts on the ground of the revolution
deleted by creator
"“Historian Michael Malet writes that at this time,“criminals entered the army for what they could get out of it, especially plunder in the towns.”
Excerpt From: Sean Patterson. “Makhno and Memory: Anarchist and Mennonite Narratives of Ukraine’s Civil War, 1917–1921.”
It's very much just denialism of Soviet success & idolizing what never "could've been" rather than accepting reality
We can't beatify Makhno and write hagiographies for a man who when:
"A delegation from Novozlatopol once went to Machno [sic] to discuss his raids against the Jews. Machno’s reply was “What can I do ? They’re just a bunch of ignorant peasants”, referring to his own men.”
deleted by creator