I’m sick of hearing about this asshole going out of his fucking way to prevent anything that would remotely benefit the working class. Sit the fucker down and tell him if he doesn’t play ball his ass is gonna get primaried. God damn the Dems suck.

  • Circra [he/him]
    ·
    4 years ago

    There was quite a popular idea regarding revolutions and social upheaval. I've seen variants of it regurgitated here and there but it goes like this.

    Revolutions and social upheaval don't happen when things are absolutely shit, they happen when the ruling classes bring in reforms that benefit the people but they don't improve things quickly enough. Broadly the French revolution tends to be given as an example here.

    Now I tend to think that the reason you might see a new ruler chuck a bunch of crumbs at the masses right before a massive revolution is that the rulers are dimly aware of the inevitability of it and having tried literally everything else attempt to placate the people with reform that comes far too little too late.

    A smart person might figure then that the best bet is to keep people happy and secure enough that this doesn't become a problem in the first place. Your average liberal politician on the other hand writes this up as a cautionary tale as to why you can never make the conditions of the masses better by even an iota or they will revolt. You can see this in all those brainfart articles implying China is playing a dangerous game in improving the material conditions of its people as they will come to expect it. Same mentality.

    Joke's on them of course cos when the shit is flying towards the fan for real you bet they will chuck everything at it, including reforms that come too little too late. Just like every out of touch ruling class before them they'll probably be quite surprised when their heads are up on pikes along the city wall, metaphorically speaking of course.

    • Ryan_Holman [he/him]
      ·
      4 years ago

      Certainly I have no idea how the future will play out, but I still don't think the United States in the 2020s is to the point of Russia in the 1910s, Cuba in the 1950s, France in the 1780s or just about any other left-wing revolution.

      This is also not to mention that a very significant amount of the population would more willing to go towards fascism.

      • Circra [he/him]
        ·
        4 years ago

        Oh absolutely. I would think that we are decades off that point. I should probably also state we're not neccessarily talking about a revolution or social upheavel that's any good -some sorta weird US brand of fascism is obviously a possibility.

        Mostly I was pointing out that particular lib theory about revolutions I have seen repeated in diff ways; that if you try and improve things somewhat for the poors they might expect more and overthrow you if they don't get it.

        • Ryan_Holman [he/him]
          ·
          4 years ago

          Gee, maybe elected officials could take action that a majority of their constituents want.

          • Circra [he/him]
            ·
            4 years ago

            I mean on a very fundamental level that probably won't happen because the majority of their constituents are working class and elected officials in a liberal democracy are ruling for the borgousie and not the prolateriat.