ChicagoCommunist [none/use name]

  • 0 Posts
  • 21 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 19th, 2024

help-circle


  • Yeah it's also a bog standard concept that's probably existed for longer than written language. You'll see similarly basic quotes attributed to most historical figures, often on fridge magnets or coffee mugs or pixelated facebook memes. Still works as a mild leftist dogwhistle I suppose.

    The concept itself is useful for the "nothing ever happens" crowd I guess, but I do worry about how much power platitudes like this have over discourse and analysis. Platitudes and even actual quotes or ideas taken out of context and projected onto whatever topic as if they're universal truths.

    Like most recently, the whole Lenin was against adventurism thing, which becomes a useless floating signifier as it gets stripped of the context Lenin was engaging with a hundred years ago. Without a careful analysis of Lenin's conditions and our own we have no idea how well his specific, nuanced conclusions apply a century later in an entirely different sociopolitical economic structure.