SleepyMarxist [none/use name]

  • 1 Post
  • 14 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 3rd, 2020

help-circle

  • SleepyMarxist [none/use name]tourbanismGreat news!!!
    ·
    3 years ago

    Consequentialism covers all morality that's based in the outcomes of actions. Utilitarianism is the kind of consequentialism focused on maximizing happiness. Deontology is rules-based morality.

    I think hypotheticals can be useful as long as the example actually is universifiable. In the trolley problem, the real question is "Is it okay to directly cause a bad thing to happen if it will prevent a worse thing (which you did not directly cause) from happening" which is IMO a worthwhile question to ask whose answer is applicable to many different scenarios. I think it's possible to misapply a hypothetical, since the scenarios might not actually be comparable, but if they are, I think we should apply our principles consistently, and having hypotheticals helps us do that.






  • I honestly think I was almost destined to be a communist. I've always had a strong dislike for the rich, a progressive worldview, and a general feeling that society is changeable and that sometimes extreme measures are acceptable to achieve that. Plus my dad drilled historical materialism into me from a young age because his dad was a communist historian.

    I just had all these barriers to taking my thoughts to their logical conclusions. Gradually, after prolonged exposure to online left spaces, those little bits of propaganda were dismantled one by one. It's not as though someone posted a big argument and I was instantly convinced, it's just that once I harbored enough doubt to stop viewing "Muh human nature" and the like as good excuses to completely dismiss the ideology, and once I understood that there were different tendencies and more nuance to the ideology than a simple caricatured Stalinism, I became able to view it clearly and to consider its arguments seriously.

    I think there are a lot of people like that, who would be very receptive to our ideas if only they were able to allow themselves to seriously consider them. This why I think it's important to challenge those little anti-communist tropes wherever you see them.