I found this podcast from this reddit-logo post:

I subbed today for a 7th and 8th grade teacher. I’m not exaggerating when I say at least 50% of the students were at a 2nd grade reading level. The students were to spend the class time filling out an “all about me” worksheet, what’s your name, favorite color, favorite food etc. I was asked 20 times today “what is this word?”. Movie. Excited. Trait. “How do I spell race car driver?”

I've only listened to one episode so far, but it's really well produced, seems well-researched and very well put together.

From what I gather so far, the ways that the American public school system "teaches" kids how to read is not only completely wrong, but actually saddles them bad habits which fundamentally hinder their reading comprehension.

A huge swath of American adults are functionally illiterate, and I think I'm starting to understand why.

  • SuperZutsuki [they/them, any]
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    The "reading recovery/whole language" people are literally a cult. There are so many quotes that boil down to, "Teaching phonics and having kids actually figure out words just felt so traditional. Reading recovery was so refreshing and Lucy Calkins is my hero!"

    There was an audio clip of a worm-brained lib going to a Lucy seminar and she could not stop gushing. "I get to see Lucy! This is the best day of my life!" and so on. These fuckers get the wall. This shit is still happening because of all the acolytes that refuse to accept the dogma of actually fucking reading to learn how to read. The Soviets, Cubans, and Chinese figured this out decades ago. America is going to become a client state of China in our lifetimes because no one knows how to do anything.

    • Flinch [he/him]
      ·
      1 year ago

      America is going to become a client state of China

      sit-back-and-enjoy

    • Egon
      ·
      edit-2
      1 month ago

      deleted by creator

      • SuperZutsuki [they/them, any]
        ·
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        Either read through some of the linked thread or listen to the first episode of the podcast. It's so dumb it's unbelievable. There's a "system" that is literally "just guess lol".

        • Egon
          ·
          edit-2
          1 month ago

          deleted by creator

          • silent_water [she/her]
            ·
            edit-2
            1 year ago

            no no, it's even worse. read the whole word is an older idea. they're teaching kids to guess the word without even looking at it. they're taught to check if they have the word right by looking at the first couple of letters. like they're teaching kids by literally covering up the word and only showing it after they guess.

            • Egon
              ·
              edit-2
              1 month ago

              deleted by creator

              • silent_water [she/her]
                ·
                1 year ago

                context, syntax, and the first couple of letters. they teach them phonics but prevent them from using it to sound out words.

                  • GarbageShoot [he/him]
                    ·
                    1 year ago

                    Cutting off their fingers so they can refine their motor skill by trying to write with their stubs.

                • Egon
                  ·
                  edit-2
                  1 month ago

                  deleted by creator

                • Melonius [he/him]
                  ·
                  1 year ago

                  You are taught to use context clues or whatever word comes to your head at first thought.

                  You might even say it's reactionary. Imagine trying to explain something to someone but they're reading a totally different sentence, based on years of US education.

            • Redcat [he/him]
              ·
              edit-2
              1 year ago

              i can't really believe what i'm reading. i'm a teacher in the global south. i don't even teach formative years, but this feels like the Three Dimensional Chess fantasy applied to pedagogy.

              • silent_water [she/her]
                ·
                1 year ago

                yeah, it's less teaching kids how to read and more purposefully sabotaging their ability to read, based on a fantasy of teaching them to love reading. it's cult woo shit.

                • Redcat [he/him]
                  ·
                  edit-2
                  1 year ago

                  why would you teach guesswork as though language is something inherent to the soul and oh fuck thats it isn't it

                  • silent_water [she/her]
                    ·
                    1 year ago

                    yep, it's literally based on the idea that if you put enough books in front of kids, they'll teach themselves how to read.

                    • Redcat [he/him]
                      ·
                      1 year ago

                      if there is one thing that is universal about teachers is that we aren't well paid. at least in some places we are actually respected and such, but still not well paid. the one thing that keeps teachers going is that its a social profession with lots of meaning behind it. what sort of teacher looks at reading and thinks its not glamorous enough to teach it step by step as a learned skill.

                      • silent_water [she/her]
                        ·
                        1 year ago

                        teachers being sold a system that comes with preplanned material, school supplies, and lots and lots of books, that promises to teach kids to love reading. it's idealism with kickbacks.

            • Farman [any]
              ·
              edit-2
              1 year ago

              Thats actually how i used to read a while back. I was taugth the normal way letter by letter. But then somtime in middle school i realised i read way too slow so i started experimenting trying to get rid of vocalization wich was the biggest inefficiency. And the solution was to grasp the meaning of the word without reading it compleatly. If its some set of consonants i cant even pronounce i cant suvvocalize them can i? Until eventually i no longer needed to do that.

              Granted i cant spell for shit. But its actually more efficient to read like that.

              It took me over a decade of trying really hard to stop my subvocalizing. If i had been taugth like you descrive from the begining i would not have had to spend so much effort to get rid of bad reading habits.

              • GarbageShoot [he/him]
                ·
                1 year ago

                It took me over a decade of trying really hard to stop my subvocalizing.

                I've never heard this term and I'm losing my mind because I'm a very slow reader and, based on what I'm seeing, more-literate people don't hear the text in their head? I literally never considered that this would be absent from reading aside from recognizing a familiar term (like the name of a store, "ambulance," whatever). God damn it . . .

                  • sappho [she/her]
                    ·
                    edit-2
                    1 year ago

                    I don't think so. I'm a very fast reader and I still kinda "hear" words in my head when I go at a relaxed pace. It's just that at a certain level of literacy, your brain has the ability to visually recognize words faster than you can mentally enunciate them, and it can also recognize words faster than you can mentally process for comprehension. I realized this when of my relatives started to play a game with me where he would flash me a paragraph on his phone for just a second or two, and then I would somehow be able to recite it back. You can deliberately make yourself read at this speed but it's not very fun, requires focus, and again, is often so fast that you start losing full comprehension of the content.

                    See the speed reading subsection here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subvocalization - in summary: everyone seems to subvocalize to varying extents, unless you deliberately train yourself not to, which you can, but you shouldn't, because it sucks.

                    • NoGodsNoMasters [they/them, she/her]
                      ·
                      1 year ago

                      One thing I've noticed is that I think I read slower and subvocalise more since I started reading theory. Like obviously when trying to fully understand a text it makes sense to take your time, but it feels like it's involuntary extended itself to other reading as well

          • HumanBehaviorByBjork [any, undecided]
            ·
            1 year ago

            I mean I don't think this method of education has ever been widespread enough to entirely explain low literacy rates in the US. There are other factors at play here.

    • sexywheat [none/use name]
      hexagon
      ·
      1 year ago

      America is going to become a client state of China in our lifetimes because no one knows how to do anything.

      Anecdotal story, and I mean no offence to Americans. I was once day-drinking on the rooftop of an airport hotel with a mate, and struck up a conversation with a chubby Danish fellow. He said he was a business owner. He noted that neither of us were Americans so he felt comfortable talking a bit of shit.

      He said his company does business with quite a few European countries, but also Americans. He said he hates dealing with Americans because every single time he had a question for them they always had to put him on hold and ask their supervisor because nobody ever seemed to know how to make a decision.

      "WHY? WHY do you have to ask your supervisor? This is a simple yes or no question!"

      And then he sighed and said "I honestly have no idea how these people made it to the moon and back".

      • SuperZutsuki [they/them, any]
        ·
        1 year ago

        There is a deep fear of responsibility and being wrong that is beaten into Americans from childhood. No one wants to be the one at fault, so they always defer to authority. It makes them into very compliant workers who also need constant supervision. People are so poorly educated they are often incapable of doing anything without direct instruction, including answering simple questions. It's real fucked up here and this podcast made me shake with rage at how much more fucked up it is for kids now. I'm just thankful my mom took an active role in my education and taught me phonics, reading, and basic math before kindergarten.

        • duderium [he/him]
          ·
          1 year ago

          In our defense, if we fuck up, we could lose our jobs, and then we're really fucked.