its october and the only horror movies i've watched are scream 1-3. they are ok for what they are (deconstruction of horror tropes via murder mystery), but i need something spicier. something existentially horrifying, not just a wrinkly monster chase or a crazy guy hacking up white girls. something that follows you out of the movie and changes how you think about the world for a few days before you're normal again. stuff that pulls at the threads of your understanding of reality. a lot of so called psychological thrillers do this but thats not specifically what i'm looking for as much as existential terror.
since i created this post i'll start with suggestions of my own
1 - SKINAMARINK
watch this without any research or info going in. all i will say is that there is limited dialogue and the amount of times you see a face or character asymptotically approaches zero. watch while stoned for maximum effect.
2 - They Look Like People
psychological thriller, avoiding spoilers but i'll say that it mayyybe leans into some problematic ableist tropes relating to mental health common to the horror genre. i have a friend that loves this movie and relates to it strongly for mental health reasons though so i might be over- or under- analyzing.
3 - The Lighthouse
monochrome period piece. 2 boys 1 lighthouse. you can probably predict how this goes but the execution is so worth it, the actors are amazing and the cinematography is excellent.
thats pretty much all i got, i haven't seen that many movies.
John Dies at the End is a very odd sort of... Surrealist horror comedy? I really liked it but I haven't seen it talked about much. The IMDB parents guide gives an idea of what you're in for: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1783732/parentalguide
Another relatively unknown horror film (afaik) is Der Todesking. It's well done for such a low budget film, but it's pretty fucked up (CW for suicide) and you'd probably want to be in the right state of mind before watching it.
Begotten is another very odd horror film (in black and white) and it's about god committing suicide and giving birth to humanity, or something.