all breadtube libs do is turn people into consumers by making them think that by watching their videos they are doing praxis , and their videos are nothing but surface analisis of media that ends with capitalism bad but they give no alternative, but VOTE for harm reduction.
Bad Mouse was right about his opinions of breadtube, that it was a scam, that didnt radicalize people , that "is about making that sweet Patreon cash by selling mildly provocative ideas to terminally online, first-world, white, insecure, mostly young people. It's a market solution (progressive, entertaining content) to a market problem (right wing content sells really well.)"
non of them i consider breadtube, Breadtube is nothing but liberals of some kind, true leftists like marxists and anarchists i dont think they are BT and they are actually good at radicalizing libs
Ah, ok then I'm in complete agreement. But the "bread" in breadtube was supposed to be for Kropotkin's Conquest of Bread, so I thought at least anarchists would be included under the umbrella.
Shrug. Again, I don't think there's a consensus on who all falls under the purview of "Breadtube," but at least initially breadtube was anarchist. Hence the name.
Like PhilosophyTube... is he lib or anarchist? He's extremely anarchist-sympathetic if he doesn't actually identify as anarchist. BadMouse even did a video with him a while back when they went to some Marxist parade or something. So there's a lot of overlap.
Yeah, go to his channel. :( All the vids are either deleted or set to private. Lotsa speculation in a couple threads on r/breadtube, some of which he responded to (but no one knew it was him because they didn't recognize the screenname) and got downvoted for.
Yeah, he's an interesting case. Started out as ancap, shifted to actual anarchist, then finally ML. I already considered myself a socialist then, but he was the first real leftist youtube channel I knew about, having thought that youtube was only a haven for the toxic and reactionary. Finding out about BadMouse, and then others, was... refreshing for sure.
I didn't know anything about LSR or badpanda at the time. Here's hoping the youtube landscape continues to grow leftward and helps radicalize more people they way it sounds like it helped you.. and me to a degree anyway. At the very least, I'm glad there's a real counter to all the fash pipelines it also platforms.
It was his own decision, but he's been pretty vague about why exactly. Seems mostly because he was unhappy with how "breadtube" was going, and just didn't want to have his face up in public anymore.
all breadtube libs do is turn people into consumers by making them think that by watching their videos they are doing praxis , and their videos are nothing but surface analisis of media that ends with capitalism bad but they give no alternative, but VOTE for harm reduction.
Like Jack Saint doing a 1 hour video about the "Revolutionary Subtext" of Space Jam?
all breadtube libs do is turn people into consumers by making them think that by watching their videos they are doing praxis , and their videos are nothing but surface analisis of media that ends with capitalism bad but they give no alternative, but VOTE for harm reduction.
Bad Mouse was right about his opinions of breadtube, that it was a scam, that didnt radicalize people , that "is about making that sweet Patreon cash by selling mildly provocative ideas to terminally online, first-world, white, insecure, mostly young people. It's a market solution (progressive, entertaining content) to a market problem (right wing content sells really well.)"
breadTube bad (except Shaun he is good)
BadMouse was good. I'm disappointed he took down his vids, but from what I've read, his reasoning for doing so was sound.
I think there's still some hope for some BreadTubers though. What about Non Compete and Luna Oi? Angie Speaks?
deleted by creator
non of them i consider breadtube, Breadtube is nothing but liberals of some kind, true leftists like marxists and anarchists i dont think they are BT and they are actually good at radicalizing libs
deleted by creator
iirc it came from a poll on r/chomsky
deleted by creator
Ah, ok then I'm in complete agreement. But the "bread" in breadtube was supposed to be for Kropotkin's Conquest of Bread, so I thought at least anarchists would be included under the umbrella.
i dont see why would anarchists want to associate with liberals who only care about looking good
Shrug. Again, I don't think there's a consensus on who all falls under the purview of "Breadtube," but at least initially breadtube was anarchist. Hence the name. Like PhilosophyTube... is he lib or anarchist? He's extremely anarchist-sympathetic if he doesn't actually identify as anarchist. BadMouse even did a video with him a while back when they went to some Marxist parade or something. So there's a lot of overlap.
Olly isn’t a lib, he’s against the housing market and talks about Marxism a bunch.
Yep. And I'd consider him a pillar of breadtube.
ollie is a ml
Where does bad empanada fall on this scale? I've seen a couple videos on Columbus and Che and he seems alright
i think he is left-comm, plus the BT subreddit kinda hates him
deleted by creator
Subscribed
Lmao this is completely wrong.
deleted by creator
Yeah, go to his channel. :( All the vids are either deleted or set to private. Lotsa speculation in a couple threads on r/breadtube, some of which he responded to (but no one knew it was him because they didn't recognize the screenname) and got downvoted for.
deleted by creator
Yeah, he's an interesting case. Started out as ancap, shifted to actual anarchist, then finally ML. I already considered myself a socialist then, but he was the first real leftist youtube channel I knew about, having thought that youtube was only a haven for the toxic and reactionary. Finding out about BadMouse, and then others, was... refreshing for sure.
deleted by creator
I didn't know anything about LSR or badpanda at the time. Here's hoping the youtube landscape continues to grow leftward and helps radicalize more people they way it sounds like it helped you.. and me to a degree anyway. At the very least, I'm glad there's a real counter to all the fash pipelines it also platforms.
i saw a few if his and enjoyed him whats the reason for removal
It was his own decision, but he's been pretty vague about why exactly. Seems mostly because he was unhappy with how "breadtube" was going, and just didn't want to have his face up in public anymore.
Removed by mod
Thought Slime is also good.
deleted by creator
I thought this was a Citations Needed fan site.
Like Jack Saint doing a 1 hour video about the "Revolutionary Subtext" of Space Jam?