[CW: is this body shaming? I'm not sure.]
I genuinely find "conventionally attractive" people (like celebrities), well, kind of ugly IMO.
This is particularly evident when you look at game mods where people can create what they consider to be the most attractive characters their imagination allows. I find most of them grotesque even. Exaggerated forms.
Che Guevara though, Che Guevara was hot. So maybe I like some conventionally attractive looks. But you know what I mean. I don't like muscle men or hyper feminine women. I prefer androgyny almost.
Anyway, just a weird shower thought.
I think it's normal. Also some people might have like 1 "normally hot feature" but in a not "normally hot face" and it makes them super attractive. It's the reason that an asymmetrical smile or a big nose are considered "distinctive" but aren't hot but a million people will say "yes I want to jump their bones." Generic "hot" people are forgettable. There are exceptions to the rule of course. But they are exceptions for a reason.