OK this is my list. But first, I need to say that this isn't a condemnation of those into such thing. They just don't vibe with me.
- Cannot get into ASMR. I've tried. Often its women 20 years younger than me, rubbing their fingernails on hairbrushes. The intentional sounds they make with their lips and fingers are things that would make me want to change seats on a bus.
- Instagram. I was maybe the last person to get a smart phone. It was probably 2016. I'm just fully lazy to take photos of stuff. This is a real issue when I'm single and I need to start putting photos on dating sites, as all pics of me in my phone are me squeezing carrots in my nostrils and similarly goofy things.
- My students' taste in anime. I try to be all cool and show off my cool taste in anime, maybe drop a Azumanga Daioh clip. It's all ancient history for 17 year olds.
- Photo and videos done in portrait mode. I guess I don't watch videos on the go. See #2
Things that the kids these days do better:
- Usually better opinions on current events than people my age
- I wish that cosplay existed when I was a teen. The default when I was younger was drugs.
If anyone insults the kids, I will visit you at your home and do an
lol, i am in my 40s and i get ASMR. big time. i remember stumbling across a community a long time ago and immediately recognizing the fumbling attempts to describe the sensation, because it's not universal and i had once tried to explain it before as a teenager and failed, embarrassingly. also, some people have certain "triggers" that others don't, or are less reliable. and sometimes the triggers are less about the action and more about the memory connecting to an earlier experience.
in those early days it was about finding/sharing videos online that gave the sensitive viewer the sensation... which is sort of like transfixing or mesmerizing. my first experience that i recall was IRL as a 1st grader when my desk neighbor was explaining a math problem to me that i already understood. just sort of quietly talking while tapping / scratching their pencil lightly. it was like being caught in something, but pleasant. another time IRL i was in a meeting with this guy who was like late 50s and he had this meandering style of speech with a low voice. same deal, i was just kind of there, locked in, and could have listened to him prattle on about literally nothing of consequence for hours. i could snap out of it, but i could feel myself not wanting to, even though the meeting was a huge waste of my time lol. i also remember getting it from watching some public access channel as a kid for a show where they did algebra on a whiteboard for some local community college. and one where they taught conversational french that was recorded in the early 80s, when they would go over conjugation. super-chouette!
the way the phenomenon has exploded i attribute to monetization, because in those early days of people looking for videos they were all these like random clips of unintentional stuff. like a guy demonstrating a suit fitting, or a transferred VHS recorded lecture on body posture. so like some youtube channel for a very niche audience would have like 15-50 views on their dozen or so videos and then one that would have like 3.2 million views lmao. and frankly, if i just search ASMR on youtube, like >95% of the content is way off the mark. like annoying, weird etc. some up close face making mouth sounds.
it's really only probably something like 1% that hits it, and usually it's not content that is made to produce ASMR. this has been recognized broadly by us ASMR enjoyers and there are entire communities that chase and curate collections of "unintentional ASMR", which honestly has a better track record in my experience.
though, there are exceptions: content makers who seem to know they are giving off the whammy and how they are doing it, but they tend to be associated with the "fascination" and "mesmerism" community which is more adjacent to weird hypnotist stuff and those grifts.
Great explanation. Explained like this I do get it better, for me it would be something like listening to music with the scratch of vinyl in it and sort of getting lost in that. Also have had this with peoples voices. Wind in certain types of trees and other auditory things like that that are just deeply pleasure inducing.
A lot of music does this to me, but not sure if this would be the same. In jazz music the sounds of the instruments on the tape for example.
I was gonna say, good explanation.
i think music could do it, or that sensation of being really dialed into a theme or motif as it unfolds. definitely wind in trees makes me think of it, because for me there's a subtly to its induction. sometimes it reminds me of what productivity-heads call "flow", when they describe this sensation of being fully focused and fully aware, but having an introspective, meditative quality to it instead of like "i'm really making great widgets for the bossman rn" or whatever the latest characterization for "functional" is.
Ok yeah, flow from some auditory things I definitely get and also seek it. So maybe it was ASMR all along.