Oathtaking and oathbreaking used to be something of a big deal. How y'all feel about going back on shit you say? Does the involvement of a holy book change your answer?

I think preoccupation with truthfulness and propriety is probably good, but what is expedient very often does not align with that. So my word probably is not bond lol

  • AlexandairBabeuf [they/them]
    hexagon
    ·
    3 years ago

    whats the difference between saying youll do something and giving your word? like promising? is a promise different from a swear?

    • GreenTeaRedFlag [any]
      ·
      3 years ago

      If someone says "hey, can you do this?" and I respond "yeah, later." I see that as just saying I'll do it. If they talk to me and say "this is important for reasons X,Y,Z, can I count on you(or something like that)" and I say "Yes, I will make sure it gets done in this fashion." I see the first as just kind of acknowledging that they spoke to me and trying to keep it in mind, but the second as actually me consciously agreeing to it. A promise could be more like my giving my word or swearing to it depending in the context. My view is my word means I am binding myself to an action and will see it done, but I could theoretically try to back out(by talking to them about it) if something else comes up or the circumstance changes. If I swear to something, I have to see it done, come hell or high water. I can come off as overdramatic about this sort of thing. This is because I am both religious and practice a code of honor, which heavily influences what I place value in.