this is mostly an answer to carnist bullshit such as "being vegan is ableist/racist/classist", pushing back against that narrative by showing that carnism is, fundamentally and systematically, all those things. You should check out Aph Ko's Racism as Zoological Witchcraft and Sunaura Taylor's Beasts of Burden for further reading on those points.
I have been reading through Racism as Zoological Witchcraft, and I agree that carnism in general is racist. However, the specific point outlined in the tweet is a systemic issue that isn't unique to animal products and can't be morally absolved just by going vegan. I hate saying it, but this is an instance where "no ethical consumption under capitalism" does apply.
sure, but abolishing capitalism wouldn't solve it either, so it's also an instance of "no ethical consumption under carnism". Everyone here knows capitalism sucks, but most libs here still don't believe carnism does, so I have to regularly hit them over the head with it
I'm not sure what you mean by "abolishing capitalism won't solve it". I think the only point outlined in the tweet that wouldn't be at least somewhat resolved by nature of communism is the wasteful usage of native land for raising animals (and the crops to feed them). (As a sidenote, I think that's the only point in the tweet that is uniquely an issue with carnism.) As workers own the means of production they wouldn't be motivated to build and run factories (In general - not just slaughterhouses) in a way that preys on marginalized people and communities and allows companies under capitalism to pay starvation wages.
working at a slaughterhouse will always be traumatising and animal AG will always be massively destructive of the environment. Even if those things didn't disproportionately affect already marginalised people they would still have to affect someone. Carnism is unsustainable is what I mean.
this is mostly an answer to carnist bullshit such as "being vegan is ableist/racist/classist", pushing back against that narrative by showing that carnism is, fundamentally and systematically, all those things. You should check out Aph Ko's Racism as Zoological Witchcraft and Sunaura Taylor's Beasts of Burden for further reading on those points.
I have been reading through Racism as Zoological Witchcraft, and I agree that carnism in general is racist. However, the specific point outlined in the tweet is a systemic issue that isn't unique to animal products and can't be morally absolved just by going vegan. I hate saying it, but this is an instance where "no ethical consumption under capitalism" does apply.
sure, but abolishing capitalism wouldn't solve it either, so it's also an instance of "no ethical consumption under carnism". Everyone here knows capitalism sucks, but most libs here still don't believe carnism does, so I have to regularly hit them over the head with it
I'm not sure what you mean by "abolishing capitalism won't solve it". I think the only point outlined in the tweet that wouldn't be at least somewhat resolved by nature of communism is the wasteful usage of native land for raising animals (and the crops to feed them). (As a sidenote, I think that's the only point in the tweet that is uniquely an issue with carnism.) As workers own the means of production they wouldn't be motivated to build and run factories (In general - not just slaughterhouses) in a way that preys on marginalized people and communities and allows companies under capitalism to pay starvation wages.
working at a slaughterhouse will always be traumatising and animal AG will always be massively destructive of the environment. Even if those things didn't disproportionately affect already marginalised people they would still have to affect someone. Carnism is unsustainable is what I mean.