The gzd post itself is dumb af and inaccurate and is just somehow trying to connect it to anarchism do dunk on it which is lame. But i lean towards against supporting Rojava as a project existing and being able to only exist through US military and geopolitical presence on Syria and the general erea (US basicaly got what it want from the erea without much pushback, be it military bases, oil field management, base of opperations for anti-iran and anti-assad opperations)
Thats cause more inocent people have died , displaced and have had their lives ruined by US presence and influence in Syria that they wouldnt have otherwise than the entire population of Rojava. Probably many times over. Hundreds of thousands of Syrian civilians have food insecurity and lack of heating because large part of the country’s breadbasket and oil fields are now unaccecible and under US sphere of influence through rojava.
There is effectively no scenario where the secular Syrian Government can become stable economicaly and geopoliticaly with US prolonging their occupation in the erea since its very presence and action there is for it to not happen. Prollonging the current situation means misery and suffering for millions of syrian citizens with no future where they will have a full belly and a safe ans stable life. And on the other side its not a question between Kurds getting slaughtered or existing under active US presence and protection. Without US occupation of the erea the Kurds will be forced to strike ,a long lasting now, deal with the Syrian state and governent to avoid getting completely genocided by the Turks and continue with some very limited regional autonomy . Syria if stable and without US meddling wouldnt let Turkey invade attack and cause such death and mayhem inside their borders and neither would kurds be genocided by Turks inside Syrias borders. Turkey wouldnt have been able to make any of its moves on the syrian Kurds and grounds without US presence and interfeerence and occupation. We saw that even with Syria as it is now since the Syrian Army was the one that kicked the Turks back last year and averted an even bigger massacre and tragedy for the Kurds who they themselves were forced to ally with Assad because of a situation thet the US put them in in the first place. So in absence of US presense the Syrian state will neither genocide nor try to completely assimilate Rojava since that would mean again exasterbating the situation into an utterly chaotic and violent civil war, becoming even weaker against the islamic oposition groups and destroying/fragmating their country.Its easy to see that they wont do that from the offers that they made. The thing Kurds lost and would lose is a big degree of regional autonomy that in many ways never had cause they never could say no to any of the US requests and decisions about what will happen in their erea
Actualy what i descirbed its whats slowly happening in the last year plus with increasing Syrian State-Rojava talks and reapproachment and diminishing US presence. So this is applies to me not really supporting them as a project existing under and only through US presence and against the mainstream in the left narrative that it HAD TO and that there WAS NO CHOICE and THAT ASSAD AND TURKS WOULD SLAUGHTER THEM OTHERWISE and so US presence is the lesser evil for them . Im happy to support the form it takes without US presence even if it is less politicaly and economicaly "autonomous"
The Americans is the greatest opressors in the erea by an insane degree, and anything else that comes close (isis) is basicaly a result of their presence and interference. People that became downtrodden by the american empire and resist against its opressive presence and occupation are both the majority comperatively to the Kurds and the group that takes precedent regarding my supporth (as long as they arent straight up islamic foundementalists) and supporting them means the complete removal of US from the region means that Rojava as a project will just lose its percieved "autonomy" and be set back massively.
The gzd post itself is dumb af and inaccurate and is just somehow trying to connect it to anarchism do dunk on it which is lame. But i lean towards against supporting Rojava as a project existing and being able to only exist through US military and geopolitical presence on Syria and the general erea (US basicaly got what it want from the erea without much pushback, be it military bases, oil field management, base of opperations for anti-iran and anti-assad opperations)
Thats cause more inocent people have died , displaced and have had their lives ruined by US presence and influence in Syria that they wouldnt have otherwise than the entire population of Rojava. Probably many times over. Hundreds of thousands of Syrian civilians have food insecurity and lack of heating because large part of the country’s breadbasket and oil fields are now unaccecible and under US sphere of influence through rojava.
There is effectively no scenario where the secular Syrian Government can become stable economicaly and geopoliticaly with US prolonging their occupation in the erea since its very presence and action there is for it to not happen. Prollonging the current situation means misery and suffering for millions of syrian citizens with no future where they will have a full belly and a safe ans stable life. And on the other side its not a question between Kurds getting slaughtered or existing under active US presence and protection. Without US occupation of the erea the Kurds will be forced to strike ,a long lasting now, deal with the Syrian state and governent to avoid getting completely genocided by the Turks and continue with some very limited regional autonomy . Syria if stable and without US meddling wouldnt let Turkey invade attack and cause such death and mayhem inside their borders and neither would kurds be genocided by Turks inside Syrias borders. Turkey wouldnt have been able to make any of its moves on the syrian Kurds and grounds without US presence and interfeerence and occupation. We saw that even with Syria as it is now since the Syrian Army was the one that kicked the Turks back last year and averted an even bigger massacre and tragedy for the Kurds who they themselves were forced to ally with Assad because of a situation thet the US put them in in the first place. So in absence of US presense the Syrian state will neither genocide nor try to completely assimilate Rojava since that would mean again exasterbating the situation into an utterly chaotic and violent civil war, becoming even weaker against the islamic oposition groups and destroying/fragmating their country.Its easy to see that they wont do that from the offers that they made. The thing Kurds lost and would lose is a big degree of regional autonomy that in many ways never had cause they never could say no to any of the US requests and decisions about what will happen in their erea
Actualy what i descirbed its whats slowly happening in the last year plus with increasing Syrian State-Rojava talks and reapproachment and diminishing US presence. So this is applies to me not really supporting them as a project existing under and only through US presence and against the mainstream in the left narrative that it HAD TO and that there WAS NO CHOICE and THAT ASSAD AND TURKS WOULD SLAUGHTER THEM OTHERWISE and so US presence is the lesser evil for them . Im happy to support the form it takes without US presence even if it is less politicaly and economicaly "autonomous"
The Americans is the greatest opressors in the erea by an insane degree, and anything else that comes close (isis) is basicaly a result of their presence and interference. People that became downtrodden by the american empire and resist against its opressive presence and occupation are both the majority comperatively to the Kurds and the group that takes precedent regarding my supporth (as long as they arent straight up islamic foundementalists) and supporting them means the complete removal of US from the region means that Rojava as a project will just lose its percieved "autonomy" and be set back massively.