As children raised in the United States of America, we were expected every morning to recite the pledge of allegiance to our country. In grade school, we were taught that our first president,...
Link to the article it's responding to: https://www.patreon.com/posts/on-american-58299798
So first, I'd like to wholeheartedly reject this Hegelian progressive historical view of "human development" as Marx did later in life and argue that the American revolution was not by any means a "positive step in the progression of Humanity." Under what circumstance is the total destruction of millions of lives and countless cultures at all positive or progressive? How can we possibly claim the foundation of the United States, which has kept millions in bondage around the globe something that has progressed humanity on iota? We will spend centuries, millennia even, undoing the damage that the American revolution and its consequences have done to this planet. The potlatch cultures of the Pacific Northwest, the tribal democratic confederacy of the Iroquois, the waterworks of the Pueblo Indians, these are far more progressive than anything the United States has produced and are examples of systems we can hope once again to emulate, all of which were stamped out.
Second, the bourgeoisie in the United Kingdom by and large were the aristocracy, and therefore were already in control of the British state long before the American Revolution. This is partially why capitalism in the modern sense came from the United Kingdom. All the American Revolution is change the hands of control from the British bourgeoisie to a local American one. And the expansion of American democracy in 1830 came part and parcel with the expansion of slavery and the genocide of native peoples.
Finally, the bourgeoisie have been in control of states for some time before the American Revolution. Venice and other Italian city states were bourgeoisie-controlled polities. The United States of the Netherlands was a bourgeoisie controlled state as well, with only a nominal alliance with the House of Orange. In fact, the "secret sauce" of the West's success and why capitalism was able to expand all across the globe, indeed the part of the definition of capitalism itself (according to some historians like Braudel) is when the state becomes identified with and amenable only to the needs of capital. It is only when the state falls into the hands of the bourgeoisie that capital is unleashed to spread unchecked across the globe, and that had been going on for long before the American Revolution.
All these people trying to retroactively rescue the conceptions of America as progressive from the 19th century all ignore the fact that what made America actually exceptional was not democracy, plenty of societies around the world had as much or more, it was free land. The USA and Canada were the one place you could go from being a serf or tenant farmer to actually owning land* and become something like an aristocrat. That is GONE, and the replacement for it, a suburban lifestyle and the job to support it*, is also GONE. America is not fucking good or special or more progressive today even on its own terms. As a trans person I can say that the only way it is more 'progressive' for us is in it's sheer incompetence of construction and inefficiency that lets some of us slip through the cracks of oppression that you see in other countries. America is a fucking shithole, that were it not for the giant pile of imperial lucre that it accidneted its way into after the second world war, would be a complete poverty riven basket case; not just a partially poverty riven basket case.
Racial and ethnic restrictions may apply, actual freedom and rights sold separately. Please see small print for further conditions, no refunds.*
So first, I'd like to wholeheartedly reject this Hegelian progressive historical view of "human development" as Marx did later in life and argue that the American revolution was not by any means a "positive step in the progression of Humanity." Under what circumstance is the total destruction of millions of lives and countless cultures at all positive or progressive? How can we possibly claim the foundation of the United States, which has kept millions in bondage around the globe something that has progressed humanity on iota? We will spend centuries, millennia even, undoing the damage that the American revolution and its consequences have done to this planet. The potlatch cultures of the Pacific Northwest, the tribal democratic confederacy of the Iroquois, the waterworks of the Pueblo Indians, these are far more progressive than anything the United States has produced and are examples of systems we can hope once again to emulate, all of which were stamped out.
Second, the bourgeoisie in the United Kingdom by and large were the aristocracy, and therefore were already in control of the British state long before the American Revolution. This is partially why capitalism in the modern sense came from the United Kingdom. All the American Revolution is change the hands of control from the British bourgeoisie to a local American one. And the expansion of American democracy in 1830 came part and parcel with the expansion of slavery and the genocide of native peoples.
Finally, the bourgeoisie have been in control of states for some time before the American Revolution. Venice and other Italian city states were bourgeoisie-controlled polities. The United States of the Netherlands was a bourgeoisie controlled state as well, with only a nominal alliance with the House of Orange. In fact, the "secret sauce" of the West's success and why capitalism was able to expand all across the globe, indeed the part of the definition of capitalism itself (according to some historians like Braudel) is when the state becomes identified with and amenable only to the needs of capital. It is only when the state falls into the hands of the bourgeoisie that capital is unleashed to spread unchecked across the globe, and that had been going on for long before the American Revolution.
All these people trying to retroactively rescue the conceptions of America as progressive from the 19th century all ignore the fact that what made America actually exceptional was not democracy, plenty of societies around the world had as much or more, it was free land. The USA and Canada were the one place you could go from being a serf or tenant farmer to actually owning land* and become something like an aristocrat. That is GONE, and the replacement for it, a suburban lifestyle and the job to support it*, is also GONE. America is not fucking good or special or more progressive today even on its own terms. As a trans person I can say that the only way it is more 'progressive' for us is in it's sheer incompetence of construction and inefficiency that lets some of us slip through the cracks of oppression that you see in other countries. America is a fucking shithole, that were it not for the giant pile of imperial lucre that it accidneted its way into after the second world war, would be a complete poverty riven basket case; not just a partially poverty riven basket case.
Racial and ethnic restrictions may apply, actual freedom and rights sold separately. Please see small print for further conditions, no refunds.*